Department of Women's and Children's Health, Karolinska Institutet, SE-171 76 Stockholm, Sweden.
Midwifery. 2013 Mar;29(3):195-202. doi: 10.1016/j.midw.2011.12.010. Epub 2012 Jul 7.
to explore the health-care providers' performance and their own perceptions of the ANC services they provide.
DESIGN, SETTING AND PARTICIPANTS: this cross-sectional exploratory survey was carried out in 2009 at four district hospitals and 18 health centres in Khammouane and Champasack provinces in rural areas of Laos.
combinations of quantitative and qualitative methods were used: (i) 59 observations of ANC sessions (components performed and equipment used); (ii) 26 semi-structured interviews with health-care providers engaged in ANC services, interpreted through content analysis. The findings indicated an overall poor quality and performance of ANC services in rural health facilities with lack of routines, scarce or insufficient equipment and limited skills among providers. The health-care providers gave an often pessimistic picture of their competence and motivation to work with ANC. Some articulated a resignation due to lack of feedback from the patients and they expressed a need for support from health-care superiors. Compared to the district hospitals, the health centres were less well-equipped and supplied, and the providers had a heavier workload, because all activities including ANC were carried out by the same provider. The average consultation time for each woman was 5mins.
the quality of ANC services in rural health facilities in Laos was poor due to lack of resources, the providers' limited skills concurrent with inadequate routines and insufficient backup from superiors.
to comply with national and international recommendations for ANC services, our suggestion is to improve the quality of the rural health facilities in Laos by providing basic equipment, support from experienced superiors and in-service training.
探索卫生保健提供者的表现及其对所提供 ANC 服务的自身认知。
设计、地点和参与者:本横断面探索性调查于 2009 年在老挝农村的 khammouane 和 champasack 省的 4 家区医院和 18 家卫生中心进行。
采用定量和定性方法相结合:(i)59 次 ANC 会议观察(开展的内容和使用的设备);(ii)对参与 ANC 服务的卫生保健提供者进行 26 次半结构访谈,通过内容分析进行解释。研究结果表明,农村卫生机构的 ANC 服务整体质量和绩效较差,常规工作缺乏,设备稀缺或不足,提供者技能有限。卫生保健提供者对自己的能力和从事 ANC 的工作动力往往持悲观态度。一些人由于缺乏患者的反馈而表示无奈,并表示需要上级的支持。与区医院相比,卫生中心的设备和用品配备较差,提供者的工作量较大,因为所有活动包括 ANC 都由同一提供者进行。每位妇女的平均咨询时间为 5 分钟。
老挝农村卫生机构的 ANC 服务质量较差,原因是资源匮乏、提供者技能有限、常规工作不足以及上级支持不足。
为了符合 ANC 服务的国家和国际建议,我们建议通过提供基本设备、有经验的上级支持和在职培训,来提高老挝农村卫生机构的质量。