Indian Institute of Public Health-Hyderabad, Public Health Foundation of India, Amar Co-operative society, Plot#1 AVN Arcade, Kavuri Hills, Madhapur, Hyderabad, Telanagana, 201010, India.
Department of Non-communicable disease epidemiology, Faculty of Epidemiology and Population Health, London School of Hygiene and Tropical Medicine, London, UK.
Reprod Health. 2019 Jul 10;16(1):100. doi: 10.1186/s12978-019-0765-y.
Appropriate antenatal care improves pregnancy outcomes. Routine antenatal care is provided at primary care facilities in rural India and women at-risk of poor outcomes are referred to advanced centres in cities. The primary care facilities include Sub-health centres, Primary health centres, and Community health centres, in ascending order of level of obstetric care provided. The latter two should provide basic and comprehensive obstetric care, respectively, but they provide only partial services. In such scenario, the management and referrals during pregnancy are less understood. This study assessed rural providers' perspectives on management and referrals of antenatal women with high obstetric risk, or with complications.
We surveyed 147 health care providers in primary level public health care from poor and better performing districts from two states. We assessed their knowledge, attitudes and practices regarding obstetric care, referral decisions and pre-referral treatments provided for commonly occurring obstetric high-risk conditions and complications.
Staff had sub-optimal knowledge of, and practices for, screening common high-risk conditions and assessing complications in pregnancy. Only 31% (47/147) mentioned screening for at least 10 of the 16 common high-risk conditions and early complications of pregnancy. Only 35% (17/49) of the staff at Primary health centres, and 51% (18/35) at Community health centres, mentioned that they managed these conditions and, the remaining staff referred most of such cases early in pregnancy. The staff mentioned inability to manage childbirth of women with high-risk conditions and complications. Thus in absence of efficient referral systems and communication, it was better for these women to receive antenatal care at the advanced centres (often far) where they should deliver. There were large gaps in knowledge of emergency treatment for obstetric complications in pregnancy and pre-referral first-aid. Staff generally were low on confidence and did not have adequate resources. Nurses had limited roles in decision making. Staff desired skill building, mentoring, moral support, and motivation from senior officers.
The Indian health system should improve the provision of obstetric care by standardising services at each level of health care and increasing the focus on emergency treatment for complications, appropriate decision-making for referral, and improving referral communication and staff support.
适当的产前护理可改善妊娠结局。印度农村的初级保健设施提供常规产前护理,有不良妊娠结局风险的妇女则被转诊至城市的高级中心。初级保健设施包括保健中心、初级保健中心和社区卫生中心,其产科护理水平依次提高。后两者应分别提供基本和全面的产科护理,但它们仅提供部分服务。在这种情况下,对妊娠高危或有并发症的孕妇的管理和转诊了解较少。本研究评估了农村提供者对有高产科风险或有并发症的产前妇女的管理和转诊的看法。
我们调查了来自两个邦的贫困和表现较好地区的 147 名初级公共卫生保健机构的卫生保健提供者。我们评估了他们在产科护理、转诊决策以及为常见产科高危情况和并发症提供的转诊前治疗方面的知识、态度和实践。
工作人员对常见高危情况的筛查和妊娠并发症的评估知识不足,实践欠佳。只有 31%(47/147)的人提到对至少 16 种常见高危情况和妊娠早期并发症进行筛查。只有 35%(49/147)的初级保健中心工作人员和 51%(35/69)的社区卫生中心工作人员提到他们管理这些情况,其余工作人员在妊娠早期将大部分此类病例转诊。工作人员提到无法管理高危产妇的分娩和并发症。因此,在没有高效的转诊系统和沟通的情况下,这些妇女最好在高级中心(通常很远)接受产前护理,她们应该在那里分娩。工作人员对妊娠并发症的紧急治疗和转诊前急救知识存在较大差距。工作人员普遍信心不足,资源不足。护士在决策方面的作用有限。工作人员希望接受高级官员的技能培训、指导、精神支持和激励。
印度卫生系统应通过标准化各级医疗保健服务来改善产科护理,重点关注并发症的紧急治疗、转诊的适当决策,以及改善转诊沟通和工作人员支持。