Boyd E J, Penston J G, Wormsley K G
Ninewells Hospital and Medical School, Dundee, Scotland.
Scand J Gastroenterol Suppl. 1990;178:72-8. doi: 10.3109/00365529009093154.
Maintenance therapy with either ranitidine or cimetidine has been administered for up to 5 years to several hundred patients suffering from duodenal or gastric ulcer disease. Maintenance treatment prevented symptomatic ulcer relapse in approximately three-quarters of patients over this period of time. About half of symptomatic ulcer relapses occurred during the 1st year of maintenance therapy, and thereafter the symptomatic recurrence rate was extremely low. Potentially the most important effect of maintenance therapy was to reduce the incidence of ulcer complications, particularly haemorrhage (from 6.2% to 0.4% during the 1st year of duodenal ulcer maintenance). Maintenance therapy is therefore likely to reduce ulcer morbidity and to be cost-beneficial in patients who have previously experienced an ulcer complication and are at an increased risk of the same complication in the future. Maintenance therapy with 300 mg ranitidine daily was more effective than 150 mg ranitidine at night in smokers and may be a useful therapeutic option for smokers who relapse during maintenance therapy with 150 mg ranitidine at night or for smokers in whom it is mandatory to prevent ulcer recurrence because of a previous complication. Asymptomatic ulcers occurring during maintenance therapy are clinically benign, and rehealing such ulcers does not alter the subsequent clinical course. Point prevalences of asymptomatic reulceration should not be used when assessing the clinical value of maintenance therapy.
已对数百名患有十二指肠溃疡或胃溃疡疾病的患者使用雷尼替丁或西咪替丁进行了长达5年的维持治疗。在这段时间里,维持治疗预防了约四分之三患者的症状性溃疡复发。约一半的症状性溃疡复发发生在维持治疗的第1年,此后症状复发率极低。维持治疗潜在的最重要作用是降低溃疡并发症的发生率,尤其是出血(十二指肠溃疡维持治疗第1年期间,出血发生率从6.2%降至0.4%)。因此,维持治疗可能会降低溃疡发病率,对于既往有溃疡并发症且未来发生相同并发症风险增加的患者具有成本效益。对于吸烟者,每日300 mg雷尼替丁的维持治疗比每晚150 mg雷尼替丁更有效,对于在每晚150 mg雷尼替丁维持治疗期间复发的吸烟者或因既往并发症而必须预防溃疡复发的吸烟者,这可能是一种有用的治疗选择。维持治疗期间出现的无症状溃疡在临床上是良性的,治愈此类溃疡不会改变随后的临床病程。评估维持治疗的临床价值时,不应使用无症状再溃疡的时点患病率。