Coryell W
University of Iowa College of Medicine, Iowa City.
Psychiatr Clin North Am. 1990 Dec;13(4):685-98.
Studies of familial transmission, twin concordance, epidemiologic patterns, and diagnostic stability on follow-up all support the fundamental separation of affective and anxiety disorders. The importance of subdividing cosyndromal conditions by the presumed primary illness follows logically from these data, and convention suggests the use of temporal sequencing to do this; however, evidence that this approach is successful is modest. At a practical level, panic attacks seem to indicate a depression of greater severity and poorer overall prognosis. Moreover, obsessions and compulsions that develop within depressive episodes tend to differ in their themes from those that develop autonomously, and depression may precipitate only certain types of phobias. Finally, panic attacks may predict better responses to MAOIs and poorer responses to conventional tricyclic antidepressants. All of these conclusions are based on a relatively small amount of literature. Interest in this topic has grown rapidly in the past decade, and subsequent reviews will draw different, or at least additional conclusions.
家族遗传、双胞胎一致性、流行病学模式以及随访中的诊断稳定性研究均支持情感障碍和焦虑障碍的基本区分。根据这些数据,按假定的原发性疾病对共病情况进行细分具有重要意义,传统做法建议使用时间顺序来进行细分;然而,这种方法成功的证据并不充分。在实际层面上,惊恐发作似乎表明抑郁程度更严重且总体预后更差。此外,在抑郁发作期间出现的强迫观念和强迫行为,其主题往往与自主出现的不同,而且抑郁可能仅引发某些类型的恐惧症。最后,惊恐发作可能预示对单胺氧化酶抑制剂反应较好,而对传统三环类抗抑郁药反应较差。所有这些结论都基于相对较少的文献。在过去十年中,对该主题的兴趣迅速增长,后续的综述将会得出不同的,或者至少是更多的结论。