Health Services Research and Development, VA San Diego Healthcare System, San Diego, CA 92161, USA.
J Altern Complement Med. 2012 Sep;18(9):832-8. doi: 10.1089/acm.2010.0657. Epub 2012 Jul 19.
Chronic low back (CLBP) pain is prevalent among military veterans and often leads to functional limitations, psychologic symptoms, lower quality of life, and higher health care costs. An increasing proportion of U.S. veterans are women, and women veterans may have different health care needs than men veterans. The purpose of this study was to assess the impact of a yoga intervention on women and men with CLBP. SUBJECTS/SETTING/INTERVENTION: VA patients with CLBP were referred by primary care providers to a clinical yoga program.
Research participants completed a brief battery of questionnaires before their first yoga class and again 10 weeks later in a single-group, pre-post study design.
Questionnaires included measures of pain (Pain Severity Scale), depression (CESD-10), energy/fatigue, and health-related quality of life (SF-12). Yoga attendance and home practice of yoga were also measured. Repeated-measures analysis of variance was used to analyze group differences over time while controlling for baseline differences.
The 53 participants who completed both assessments had a mean age of 53 years, and were well educated, 41% nonwhite, 49% married, and had varying employment status. Women participants had significantly larger decreases in depression (p=0.046) and pain "on average" (p=0.050), and larger increases in energy (p=0.034) and SF-12 Mental Health (p=0.044) than men who participated. The groups did not differ significantly on yoga attendance or home practice of yoga.
These results suggest that women veterans may benefit more than men veterans from yoga interventions for chronic back pain. Conclusions are tentative because of the small sample size and quasi-experimental study design. A more rigorous study is being designed to answer these research questions more definitively.
慢性下背痛(CLBP)疼痛在退伍军人中很常见,常导致功能受限、心理症状、生活质量下降和医疗保健费用增加。越来越多的美国退伍军人是女性,女性退伍军人的医疗保健需求可能与男性退伍军人不同。本研究旨在评估瑜伽干预对慢性下背痛女性和男性退伍军人的影响。
受试者/设置/干预:退伍军人事务部(VA)慢性下背痛患者由初级保健提供者转介至临床瑜伽项目。
研究参与者在参加第一次瑜伽课前和 10 周后完成了一份简短的问卷,采用单组、前后测设计。
问卷包括疼痛(疼痛严重程度量表)、抑郁(CESD-10)、能量/疲劳和健康相关生活质量(SF-12)的测量。还测量了瑜伽出勤率和在家练习瑜伽的情况。使用重复测量方差分析来分析随时间的组间差异,同时控制基线差异。
完成两项评估的 53 名参与者平均年龄为 53 岁,教育程度较高,41%为非白人,49%已婚,就业状况各不相同。与男性参与者相比,女性参与者的抑郁(p=0.046)和疼痛“平均”(p=0.050)显著降低,能量(p=0.034)和 SF-12 心理健康(p=0.044)显著增加。两组在瑜伽出勤率或在家练习瑜伽方面没有显著差异。
这些结果表明,瑜伽干预可能对慢性下背痛女性退伍军人的益处大于男性退伍军人。由于样本量小和准实验设计,结论尚不确定。正在设计一项更严格的研究来更明确地回答这些研究问题。