Specialist Endodontist, London, UK.
Int Endod J. 2013 Feb;46(2):137-44. doi: 10.1111/j.1365-2591.2012.02098.x. Epub 2012 Jul 24.
To evaluate the specific alterations in tooth colour with white and grey MTA when used to fill pulp chambers.
Forty-five fully developed, intact, mandibular third molars were sectioned 1 mm below their cemento-enamel junction (CEJ). Their pulp chambers were chemo-mechanically debrided, and the specimens were randomly assigned into three groups: Group 1-white MTA (Angelus(™)), Group 2-grey MTA (Angelus(™)) and Group 3-negative control (unfilled). During the experimental period, specimens were immersed in vials containing distilled water up to the CEJ (37±1 °C). Spectral reflectance lines were recorded by utilizing a UV-vis spectrophotometer equipped with an integration sphere in the visual spectrum, at baseline, 1 week and 1, 2 and 3 months after placement of the materials. Data were transformed into values of the CIE Lab* colour system, and the corresponding ΔΕ values were calculated. The results were analysed using two-way mixed anova models, whilst pairwise comparisons were conducted with Bonferroni's method at P < 0.05 level of significance.
Both types of MTA induced significant decreases in L*, a* and b* values. The colour change was greater with grey MTA. Grey MTA led to clinically perceptible crown discolouration after 1 month, whilst the total colour change caused by white MTA exceeded the perceptible threshold for the human eye after 3 months.
The application of both grey and white MTA formulations induced a decrease in lightness and reduction in redness and yellowness in teeth. The present findings suggest that application of grey MTA in the aesthetic zone should be avoided, whilst white MTA should be used with caution when filling pulp chambers with the materials.
评估使用白色和灰色 MTA 填充牙髓腔时牙齿颜色的具体变化。
将 45 颗完全发育、完整、下颌第三磨牙在距牙釉牙骨质界(CEJ)下方 1 毫米处进行切片。用化学机械方法对其牙髓腔进行清创,然后将标本随机分为三组:第 1 组-白色 MTA(Angelus(™))、第 2 组-灰色 MTA(Angelus(™))和第 3 组-阴性对照(未填充)。在实验期间,标本被浸泡在装有蒸馏水的小瓶中,直至 CEJ(37±1°C)。使用配备积分球的 UV-vis 分光光度计在可见光谱中记录光谱反射线,在基线、放置材料后 1 周和 1、2 和 3 个月时进行记录。数据转换为 CIE Lab*颜色系统的值,并计算相应的ΔΕ值。使用双向混合方差分析模型分析结果,并用 Bonferroni 方法进行两两比较,置信度水平为 0.05。
两种类型的 MTA 均导致 L*、a和 b值显著降低。灰色 MTA 引起的颜色变化更大。灰色 MTA 在 1 个月后导致牙冠明显变色,而白色 MTA 在 3 个月后引起的总颜色变化超过人眼的可察觉阈值。
应用灰色和白色 MTA 制剂均会降低牙齿的明度并减少红色和黄色调。本研究结果表明,在美学区域应用灰色 MTA 应避免,而在使用这些材料填充牙髓腔时应谨慎使用白色 MTA。