Kouloussis Nikos A, Papadopoulos Nikos T, Müller Hans-Georg, Wang Jane-Ling, Mao Meng, Katsoyannos Byron I, Duyck Pierre-François, Carey James R
Laboratory of Applied Zoology and Parasitology, School of Agriculture, Aristotle University of Thessaloniki, 54124 Thessaloniki, Greece.
Entomol Exp Appl. 2009 Aug 1;132(2):172-181. doi: 10.1111/j.1570-7458.2009.00879.x. Epub 2009 Jul 13.
Though traps are used widely to sample phytophagous insects for research or management purposes, and recently in aging research, possible bias stemming from differential response of individuals of various ages to traps has never been examined. In this paper, we tested the response of Ceratitis capitata (Wiedemann) (Diptera: Tephritidae) males and females of four ages (spanning from 1 to 40 days) to McPhail-type traps baited with a synthetic food attractant in field cages and found that the probability of trapping was significantly influenced by age. The type of food on which flies were maintained before testing (sugar or protein) also had a strong effect and interacted with age. In another experiment, we collected wild C. capitata adults of unknown age using 1-3 methods and then reared them in the laboratory until death. The survival schedules of these flies were subsequently used in a life table assay to infer their age at the time of capture. Results showed that on a single sampling date, males captured in traps baited with a food attractant were younger compared with males aspirated from fruiting host trees, or males captured in traps baited with a sex attractant. Likewise, females captured in food-baited traps were younger compared with aspirated females. In addition to providing the first evidence of age-dependent sampling bias for a phytophagous insect species, this paper also provides a novel approach to estimate the differences in the age composition of samples collected with different techniques. These findings are of utmost importance for several categories of insects, medically important groups notwithstanding.
尽管诱捕器被广泛用于采集植食性昆虫以进行研究或管理,最近还用于衰老研究,但不同年龄个体对诱捕器的不同反应可能导致的偏差从未得到研究。在本文中,我们在田间网笼中测试了四种年龄(1至40天)的地中海实蝇(Ceratitis capitata (Wiedemann),双翅目:实蝇科)雌雄成虫对装有合成食物引诱剂的麦克费尔型诱捕器的反应,发现诱捕概率受年龄显著影响。测试前饲养果蝇的食物类型(糖或蛋白质)也有很大影响,并与年龄相互作用。在另一个实验中,我们用1至3种方法收集了年龄未知的野生地中海实蝇成虫,然后在实验室饲养直至死亡。这些果蝇的存活时间表随后用于生命表分析,以推断它们被捕时的年龄。结果表明,在单个采样日期,用食物引诱剂诱捕的雄蝇比从结果寄主树上吸出的雄蝇或用性引诱剂诱捕的雄蝇年轻。同样,用食物诱捕器捕获的雌蝇比吸出的雌蝇年轻。除了为一种植食性昆虫物种提供年龄依赖性采样偏差的首个证据外,本文还提供了一种新方法来估计用不同技术采集的样本在年龄组成上的差异。这些发现对几类昆虫至关重要,医学上重要的群体也不例外。