Napal Olatz, Ojeda Natalia, Sánchez Pedro, Elizagárate Edorta, Peña Javier, Ezcurra Jesús, Gutiérrez Miguel
Hospital de Santiago Apóstol, Spain.
Actas Esp Psiquiatr. 2012 Jul-Aug;40(4):198-220. Epub 2012 Jul 1.
There has been increasing interest about cognition in schizophrenia during recent years. The greater focus of the investigators has been focused greater interest on the relation of cognitive deterioration with positive and negative symptoms, and functionality. However very few studies, if any, have specifically focused on the course of cognition in schizophrenic patients throughout the years. Those who have attempted to answer this question have done so by comparing cross-sectional studies of patients at different stages of their disease. Only a minority have used a longitudinal methodology in their studies. This article reviews a total of 31 cross-sectional and 43 longitudinal studies published in patients with a diagnosis of schizophrenia. The diversity of criteria and methods used significantly limits the conclusions that can be drawn. After a comprehensive review of the literature on this topic, the authors have come to the conclusion that there are two opposite trends: 1) Cognition in schizophrenia follows a progressive decline over the years of evolution of the disease (a conclusion predominant in studies with cross-sectional methodology) and 2) Cognition in schizophrenia remains stable once it appears during the first stages of the disease (a conclusion predominant in longitudinal studies). The authors conclude that the question about the likely decline of cognition in schizophrenia cannot be answered due to the lack of rigorous and thorough follow-up studies.
近年来,人们对精神分裂症中的认知越来越感兴趣。研究者们更多地将关注点集中在认知衰退与阳性和阴性症状以及功能之间的关系上。然而,极少有研究(如果有的话)专门关注精神分裂症患者多年来认知的发展过程。那些试图回答这个问题的研究,是通过比较处于疾病不同阶段患者的横断面研究来进行的。只有少数研究采用了纵向研究方法。本文综述了总共31项针对精神分裂症患者的横断面研究和43项纵向研究。所使用标准和方法的多样性显著限制了能够得出的结论。在对该主题的文献进行全面综述后,作者们得出结论:存在两种相反的趋势:1)在疾病发展的数年中,精神分裂症患者的认知呈渐进性衰退(这一结论在横断面研究方法的研究中占主导);2)精神分裂症患者的认知一旦在疾病的最初阶段出现,就会保持稳定(这一结论在纵向研究中占主导)。作者们得出结论,由于缺乏严谨和全面的随访研究,关于精神分裂症患者认知是否可能衰退的问题无法得到解答。