Academic Medical Center, Amsterdam, The Netherlands.
Rhinology. 2012 Sep;50(3):255-61. doi: 10.4193/Rhino12.050.
To assess the quality of life (QOL) impact of extended endonasal approaches and nasoseptal flap reconstruction for benign skull base tumours
A random sample of 110 patients undergoing either limited endonasal transphenoidal hypophysectomy or extended endonasal approaches (trans-cribriform, trans-sellar, trans-tuberculum, trans-pterygoid) for the removal of benign skull base tumours were asked to complete Rhinosinusitis Outcome Measure (RSOM-31) questionnaire.
A total of 91 patients returned the completed questionnaire. All patients in the limited approach group had pituitary adenomas, while patients in the extended group had a variety of tumours including adenomas with suprasellar or cavernous extension, chordomas, meningiomas, craniopharyngiomas and dermoids. Median time to completion of questionnaire was 1104 days in the limited group and 142 days in the extended approaches group. Although smell and headache were significantly worse in the group undergoing reconstruction with Haddad flap, there was no significant difference in overall, nasal, general, emotional or sleep quality of life between the two groups. Both smell and headache showed significant improvement with time. In linear regression, the single most important factor independently associated with overall worse RSOM-31 total scores was the presence of secreting adenomas.
The use of nasoseptal flap appears to have a limited negative impact in nasal quality of life, mainly related to heada- che and reduced smell, both of which tend to improve with time. Hormone-secreting tumours have the most important adverse effect in quality of life extending in general, emotional, sleep and overall wellbeing, as reflected in RSOM 31 subscales.
评估扩展经鼻内镜入路和鼻中隔瓣重建对良性颅底肿瘤患者生活质量(QOL)的影响
随机抽取 110 例接受经蝶窦有限内镜切除术或扩展经鼻内镜入路(经筛骨、经蝶鞍、经鞍结节、经翼突)切除良性颅底肿瘤的患者,要求其完成鼻-鼻窦炎结局测量(RSOM-31)问卷。
共有 91 例患者返回了完整的问卷。所有接受有限入路组的患者均为垂体腺瘤,而扩展入路组的患者则患有多种肿瘤,包括伴有鞍上或海绵窦扩展的腺瘤、脊索瘤、脑膜瘤、颅咽管瘤和皮样囊肿。在有限组中完成问卷的中位数时间为 1104 天,在扩展组中为 142 天。虽然接受 Haddad 瓣重建的患者嗅觉和头痛明显更差,但两组之间的总体、鼻部、一般、情绪或睡眠生活质量均无显著差异。嗅觉和头痛均随时间显著改善。在线性回归中,与 RSOM-31 总评分整体较差相关的唯一最重要因素是存在分泌性腺瘤。
使用鼻中隔瓣似乎对鼻腔生活质量有一定的负面影响,主要与头痛和嗅觉减退有关,两者均随时间推移而改善。分泌性肿瘤对生活质量的总体、情绪、睡眠和整体健康状况产生最重要的不利影响,这反映在 RSOM 31 子量表中。