Department of Psychology, University of Toronto Mississauga, Mississauga, Ontario, Canada.
Psychol Sci. 2012 Oct 1;23(10):1074-8. doi: 10.1177/0956797612442552. Epub 2012 Aug 15.
Across species, there is considerable evidence of preferential processing for biologically significant signals such as conspecific vocalizations and the calls of individual conspecifics. Surprisingly, music cognition in human listeners is typically studied with stimuli that are relatively low in biological significance, such as instrumental sounds. The present study explored the possibility that melodies might be remembered better when presented vocally rather than instrumentally. Adults listened to unfamiliar folk melodies, with some presented in familiar timbres (voice and piano) and others in less familiar timbres (banjo and marimba). They were subsequently tested on recognition of previously heard melodies intermixed with novel melodies. Melodies presented vocally were remembered better than those presented instrumentally even though they were liked less. Factors underlying the advantage for vocal melodies remain to be determined. In line with its biological significance, vocal music may evoke increased vigilance or arousal, which in turn may result in greater depth of processing and enhanced memory for musical details.
跨物种研究表明,生物信号(如同种生物的叫声和个体的叫声)具有优先处理的优势。令人惊讶的是,人类听众的音乐认知通常是通过研究具有较低生物意义的刺激物来进行的,例如乐器声音。本研究探讨了旋律以声乐形式呈现是否比以器乐形式呈现时更容易被记住的可能性。成年人听了不熟悉的民间旋律,有些是以熟悉的音色(人声和钢琴)呈现,有些是以不太熟悉的音色(班卓琴和马林巴琴)呈现。随后,他们在识别以前听过的旋律与新旋律混合的测试中表现如何。尽管声乐呈现的旋律不太受欢迎,但它们的记忆效果却优于器乐呈现的旋律。声乐旋律优势的背后因素仍有待确定。考虑到其生物意义,声乐音乐可能会引起更高的警觉或唤醒,这反过来又可能导致对音乐细节的处理更加深入,并增强记忆。