Department of Community Health, School of Medical Sciences, College of Health Sciences, Kwame Nkrumah University of Science and Technology, UPO, PMB, KNUST, Kumasi, Ghana.
Malar J. 2012 Aug 16;11:277. doi: 10.1186/1475-2875-11-277.
The contribution of community medicine distributors (CMD) to prompt health service delivery in areas described as "hard-to-reach" is important but the value of their work time remains unknown and thus makes it difficult to design appropriate regular financial incentives to motivate them. This makes CMDs feel their efforts are not recognized. An attempt to estimate the value of 54 CMDs' work time involved in community case management of malaria (CCMm) in a rural district in Ghana is presented.
Time spent by CMDs on CCMm activities were recorded for a period of 12 months to determine the work-time value. Cost analysis was performed in Microsoft Excel with data from CMD records and at 2007 market price in Ghana.
A CMD spent 4.8 hours, [95% CI: 3.9; 5.3] on all CCMm-related activities per day. The time value of CMD work ranged from GH¢ 2.04 (US$ 2.24) to GH¢ 4.1 [US$ 4.6] per week and GH¢ 19.2 - 86.4 (US$ 21.10-94.95) per month. The gross wage outside CCMm as reported by CMD was GH¢ 58.4 [US$ 64.69] and value of foregone income of GH¢ 86.40 (US$ 94.95) per month, about 14-times higher than the monthly incentives of GH¢ 6.0 given by the CCMm programme.
The value of work time and the foregone income of CMDs in CCMm are high and yet there are no regular and sustainable incentives provided for them. The results are significant to policy in designing incentives to motivate CMDs in large-scale implementation of CCMm.
社区医药经销商(CMD)在所谓的“难以到达”地区提供及时的卫生服务,这对他们的贡献非常重要,但他们的工作时间价值却未知,这使得设计适当的定期财务激励措施来激励他们变得困难。这使得 CMD 感到他们的努力没有得到认可。本文试图估计加纳一个农村地区 54 名 CMD 在社区疟疾病例管理(CCMm)中的工作时间价值。
记录 CMD 参与 CCMm 活动的时间,以确定工作时间价值。在 Microsoft Excel 中进行成本分析,数据来自 CMD 记录和 2007 年加纳的市场价格。
CMD 每天花 4.8 小时[95%置信区间:3.9;5.3]从事所有与 CCMm 相关的活动。CMD 工作时间的价值范围为每周 GH¢2.04(US$2.24)至 GH¢4.1[US$4.6],每月 GH¢19.2-86.4(US$21.10-94.95)。CMD 报告的 CCMm 以外的总工资为 GH¢58.4[US$64.69],每月损失的收入为 GH¢86.40(US$94.95),约为 CCMm 计划每月提供的 GH¢6.0 激励的 14 倍。
CMD 在 CCMm 中的工作时间价值和损失的收入都很高,但他们没有得到定期和可持续的激励。这些结果对于设计激励措施以激励 CMD 在大规模实施 CCMm 方面具有重要意义。