Meier Andreas H, Boehler Maggie L, McDowell Chris M, Schwind Cathy, Markwell Steve, Roberts Nicole K, Sanfey Hilary
Division of Pediatric Surgery, Department of Surgery, SUNY Upstate Medical University, 725 Irving Ave, Ste 401, Syracuse, NY 13210-2306, USA.
Arch Surg. 2012 Aug;147(8):761-6. doi: 10.1001/archsurg.2012.1340.
To investigate whether the existing Team Strategies and Tools to Enhance Performance and Patient Safety (TeamSTEPPS) curriculum can effectively teach senior medical students team skills. DESIGN Single-group preintervention and postintervention study.
We integrated a TeamSTEPPS module into our existing resident readiness elective. The curriculum included interactive didactic sessions, discussion groups, role-plays, and videotaped immersive simulation scenarios.
Improvement of self-assessment scores, multiple-choice examination scores, and performance ratings of videotaped simulation scenarios before and after intervention. The videos were rated by masked reviewers on the basis of a global rating instrument (TeamSTEPPS) and a more detailed nontechnical skills evaluation tool(NOTECHS).
Seventeen students participated and completed the study.
The self-evaluation scores improved from 12.76 to 16.06 (P < .001). The increase was significant for all of the TeamSTEPPS competencies and highest for leadership skills (from 2.2 to 3.2; P < .001). The multiple-choice score rose from 84.9% to 94.1% (P < .01). The postintervention video ratings were significantly higher for both instruments (TeamSTEPPS, from 2.99 to 3.56; P < .01; and NOTECHS, from 4.07 to 4.59; P < .001).
The curriculum led to improved self-evaluation and multiple-choice scores as well as improved team skills during simulated immersive patient encounters. The TeamSTEPPS framework may be suitable for teaching medical students teamwork concepts and improving their competencies. Larger studies using this framework should be considered to further evaluate the generalizability of our results and the effectiveness of TeamSTEPPS for medical students.
探讨现有的提高绩效与患者安全的团队策略和工具(TeamSTEPPS)课程能否有效教授高年级医学生团队技能。设计:单组干预前和干预后研究。
我们将一个TeamSTEPPS模块整合到现有的住院医师准备选修课程中。该课程包括互动式教学课程、讨论小组、角色扮演和录像沉浸式模拟场景。
干预前后自我评估分数、多项选择题考试分数以及录像模拟场景表现评分的改善情况。录像由不知情的评审人员根据整体评分工具(TeamSTEPPS)和更详细的非技术技能评估工具(NOTECHS)进行评分。
17名学生参与并完成了研究。
自我评估分数从12.76提高到16.06(P < .001)。所有TeamSTEPPS能力的分数均显著提高,领导技能提高最为显著(从2.2提高到3.2;P < .001)。多项选择题分数从84.9%提高到94.1%(P < .01)。两种工具的干预后录像评分均显著更高(TeamSTEPPS,从2.99提高到3.56;P < .01;NOTECHS,从4.07提高到4.59;P < .001)。
该课程在模拟沉浸式患者诊疗过程中提高了自我评估和多项选择题分数以及团队技能。TeamSTEPPS框架可能适用于教授医学生团队合作概念并提高他们的能力。应考虑使用该框架进行更大规模的研究,以进一步评估我们结果的普遍性以及TeamSTEPPS对医学生的有效性。