Institute of Palliative Care, Oldenburg, Germany.
J Pain Symptom Manage. 2013 Mar;45(3):561-78. doi: 10.1016/j.jpainsymman.2012.02.022. Epub 2012 Aug 24.
Although episodic breathlessness (EB) is reported to be highly prevalent in advanced disease, our understanding about it is limited.
The aim of this study was to systematically review and synthesize the evidence on EB regarding definition, characteristics, and patients' experiences.
Systematic review using searches in six databases, hand search, and personal contacts with authors in the field. Search terms included the combination of "episodic" and "breathlessness" (and synonyms) with five different diseases. Selection criteria included patients with advanced disease and information about EB based on original research. All retrieved studies were reviewed by two independent investigators.
Twenty-seven studies (of 7584) were included in this review. Only eight studies explored EB as a primary outcome. EB is poorly defined. It is characterized by high prevalence (81%-85%), high frequency (daily), short duration (often less than 10 minutes), and severe peak intensity. EB either develops without any known trigger or is triggered by physical exertion, emotions, or environmental influences.
EB is a common symptom in patients with advanced disease, but information about characteristics and experiences is limited. As there is no common terminology, an agreed definition is needed to foster research to develop effective treatments for EB.
虽然在晚期疾病中,间歇性呼吸困难(EB)的报告发生率很高,但我们对其的了解有限。
本研究旨在系统地回顾和综合关于 EB 的定义、特征和患者体验的证据。
使用六个数据库进行系统检索、手工检索以及与该领域作者的个人联系。检索词包括“间歇性”和“呼吸困难”(及其同义词)与五种不同疾病的组合。选择标准包括晚期疾病患者和基于原始研究的 EB 信息。所有检索到的研究均由两名独立的研究者进行审查。
本综述共纳入 27 项研究(7584 项中的 27 项)。仅有 8 项研究将 EB 作为主要结局进行了探索。EB 定义不明确。其特征为高发生率(81%-85%)、高频率(每日)、短持续时间(通常少于 10 分钟)和严重的峰值强度。EB 要么没有任何已知的触发因素而发展,要么由体力活动、情绪或环境影响触发。
EB 是晚期疾病患者的常见症状,但关于其特征和体验的信息有限。由于没有通用的术语,因此需要一个商定的定义,以促进针对 EB 的有效治疗方法的研究。