Department of Otorhinolaryngology, Medical School, Ufuk University, Ankara,Turkey.
Bosn J Basic Med Sci. 2012 Aug;12(3):151-7. doi: 10.17305/bjbms.2012.2462.
The aim of this study compares to the increase in tissue temperature and the thermal histological effects of ultrasonic scalpel, bipolar and unipolar electrosurgery incisions in the tongue tissue of rabbits. This study evaluates the histopathological changes related to thermal change and the maximum temperature values in the peripheral tissue brought about by the incisions carried out by the three methods in a comparative way. To assess thermal tissue damage induced by the three instruments, maximum tissue temperatures were measured during the surgical procedure and tongue tissue samples were examined histopathologically following the surgery. The mean maximum temperature values of the groups were 93.93±2.76 Cº for the unipolar electrocautery group, whereas 85.07±5.95 Cº for the bipolar electrocautery group, and 108.23±7.64 Cº for the ultrasonic scalpel group. There was a statistically significant relationship between the increase in maximum temperature values and the separation among tissue layers, edema, congestion, necrosis, hemorrhage, destruction in blood vessel walls and fibrin accumulation, and between the existence of fibrin thrombus and tissue damage depth (p<0.05). It was concluded that the bipolar electrocautery use gives way to less temperature increase in the tissues and less thermal tissue damage in comparison to the other methods.
本研究旨在比较超声刀、双极和单极电刀在兔舌组织中的组织温度升高和热组织学效应。本研究通过比较三种方法的切口,评估与热变化相关的组织病理学变化和周围组织的最高温度值。为了评估三种仪器引起的热组织损伤,在手术过程中测量了组织的最高温度,并在手术后对舌组织样本进行了组织病理学检查。单极电刀组的平均最高温度值为 93.93±2.76°C,双极电刀组为 85.07±5.95°C,超声刀组为 108.23±7.64°C。最高温度值的增加与组织分层、水肿、充血、坏死、出血、血管壁破坏和纤维蛋白积聚之间存在统计学显著关系,与纤维蛋白血栓的存在和组织损伤深度之间也存在统计学显著关系(p<0.05)。结论是与其他方法相比,双极电刀的使用会导致组织温度升高减少,热组织损伤减少。