Ortu Daniele
University of Stirling, Via Nuoro 16, 09045 Quartu S.E., Italy.
Behav Anal. 2012 Spring;35(1):75-87. doi: 10.1007/BF03392267.
In radical behaviorism, the difference between overt and covert responses does not depend on properties of the behavior but on the sensitivity of the measurement tools employed by the experimenter. Current neuroscientific research utilizes technologies that allow measurement of variables that are undetected by the tools typically used by behavior analysts. Data from a specific neuroscientific technique, event-related potential (ERP), suggest that emission of otherwise covert responses can be indexed and that such covert responses are sensitive to stimulus control and selection by consequences. The P3 ERP effect is proposed as indicative of emission. Moreover, ERP results in semantic priming experiments suggest that operants are sensitive to changes in stimulus control even when they are not emitted (latent responses). Changes in response strength of latent responses as a function of stimulus control can in fact be measured by reaction time data and an ERP dependent variable called the N400 effect. If the interpretations provided in this paper are accurate, an index of covertly emitted operants (P3 effect) constitutes experimental evidence suggesting the validity of a Skinnerian radical behaviorist perspective on behavior. Moreover, in a Skinnerian paradigm, measured fluctuations in the response strength of latent operants as a function of environmental changes (N400 effect) would validate Palmer's (2009) concept of the repertoire.
在激进行为主义中,公开反应与隐蔽反应之间的差异并不取决于行为的属性,而是取决于实验者所采用测量工具的敏感度。当前的神经科学研究运用的技术能够测量行为分析家常用工具无法检测到的变量。来自一种特定神经科学技术——事件相关电位(ERP)的数据表明,原本隐蔽的反应的发出可以被标记,并且这种隐蔽反应对刺激控制和后果选择敏感。P3 ERP效应被认为是反应发出的指标。此外,语义启动实验中的ERP结果表明即使操作行为未发出(潜在反应),它们对刺激控制的变化也很敏感。潜在反应的反应强度随刺激控制的变化实际上可以通过反应时间数据和一个名为N400效应的ERP因变量来测量。如果本文提供的解释是准确的,那么隐蔽发出的操作行为的指标(P3效应)构成了实验证据,表明斯金纳式激进行为主义对行为的观点是有效的。此外,在斯金纳式范式中,潜在操作行为的反应强度随环境变化的测量波动(N400效应)将验证帕尔默(2009)的行为 repertoire概念。