Schaefer C M, Greene R, Oestmann J W, Hall D A, Llewellyn H J, McCarthy K A, Pile-Spellman E R, Rubens J R
Department of Radiology, Massachusetts General Hospital, Boston.
Radiology. 1990 Jan;174(1):207-10. doi: 10.1148/radiology.174.1.2294549.
The advantages of imaging the chest with digital storage phosphor radiography (SR) may be nullified by its spatial resolution, which is lower than that of conventional film radiography (FR). To test the reader detection performance with the two modalities under clinical conditions, the authors compared 140-kVp isoexposure SR (system resolution: 0.2 mm, 10 bits) and FR images of a variety of chest abnormalities proved by computed tomography (CT) (157 patients, 244 abnormalities, 5,652 observations, six readers). In all tests, SR was as good as or better than FR (P less than .05). In overall detection, indicated by the average area of receiver operating characteristics, SR and FR were equivalent. SR was superior for mediastinal lesions and for pulmonary opacities greater than 2 cm in diameter. For all other types of pulmonary lesions and pleural abnormalities, SR and FR were equivalent. Currently available commercial SR systems can replace film radiographic systems in the detection of a wide variety of chest lesions. SR is likely to enable better visualization than FR in the detection of mediastinal and large pulmonary abnormalities.
用数字存储磷光体射线照相术(SR)对胸部进行成像的优势可能会因其空间分辨率低于传统胶片射线照相术(FR)而被抵消。为了在临床条件下测试两种成像方式下阅片者的检测性能,作者比较了140 kVp等剂量的SR(系统分辨率:0.2毫米,10比特)图像和经计算机断层扫描(CT)证实的各种胸部异常的FR图像(157例患者,244处异常,5652次观察,6名阅片者)。在所有测试中,SR与FR表现相当或更优(P小于0.05)。以平均受试者工作特征曲线面积表示的总体检测中,SR和FR相当。SR在检测纵隔病变和直径大于2厘米的肺部混浊方面更具优势。对于所有其他类型的肺部病变和胸膜异常,SR和FR相当。目前可用的商用SR系统在检测各种胸部病变方面可以取代胶片射线照相系统。在检测纵隔和大型肺部异常方面,SR可能比FR能实现更好的可视化。