Lette J, Waters D, Lassonde J, Dubé S, Heyen F, Picard M, Morin M
Department of Medicine, Maisonneuve-Rosemont Hospital, Montreal, Canada.
Ann Surg. 1990 Jan;211(1):84-90. doi: 10.1097/00000658-199001000-00015.
Sixty-six patients unable to complete a standard preoperative exercise test because of physical limitations were studied to determine the predictive value of individual clinical parameters, of clinical scoring systems based on multifactorial analysis, and of dipyridamole-thallium imaging before major general and vascular surgery. Study endpoints were limited to postoperative myocardial infarction or cardiac death before hospital discharge. There were nine postoperative cardiac events (seven deaths and two nonfatal infarctions). There was no statistical correlation between cardiac events and preoperative clinical descriptors, including individual clinical parameters, the Dripps-American Surgical Association score, the Goldman Cardiac Risk Index score, the Detsky Modified Cardiac Risk Index score, Eagle's clinical markers of low surgical risk, and the probability of postoperative events as determined by Cooperman's equation. There were no cardiac events in 30 patients with normal dipyridamole-thallium scans or in nine patients with fixed myocardial perfusion defects. Of 21 patients with reversible perfusion defects who underwent surgery, nine had a postoperative cardiac event (sensitivity, 100%; specificity, 43%). In the six other patients with reversible defects, preoperative angiography showed severe coronary disease or cardiomyopathy. Thus in patients unable to complete a standard exercise stress test, postoperative outcome cannot be predicted clinically before major general and vascular surgery, whereas dipyridamole-thallium imaging successfully identified all patients who sustained a postoperative cardiac event.
对66例因身体限制无法完成标准术前运动试验的患者进行了研究,以确定个体临床参数、基于多因素分析的临床评分系统以及双嘧达莫-铊心肌显像在大型普通外科和血管外科手术前的预测价值。研究终点仅限于出院前的术后心肌梗死或心源性死亡。共有9例术后心脏事件(7例死亡和2例非致命性梗死)。心脏事件与术前临床描述指标之间无统计学相关性,这些指标包括个体临床参数、Dripps-美国外科协会评分、Goldman心脏风险指数评分、Detsky改良心脏风险指数评分、Eagle低手术风险临床标志物以及Cooperman方程确定的术后事件概率。30例双嘧达莫-铊扫描正常的患者或9例有固定心肌灌注缺损的患者未发生心脏事件。在21例接受手术的有可逆性灌注缺损的患者中,9例发生了术后心脏事件(敏感性为100%;特异性为43%)。在其他6例有可逆性缺损的患者中,术前血管造影显示有严重冠状动脉疾病或心肌病。因此,在无法完成标准运动负荷试验的患者中,在大型普通外科和血管外科手术前,临床上无法预测术后结果,而双嘧达莫-铊心肌显像成功识别了所有发生术后心脏事件的患者。