Maternal and Fetal health Research Centre, University of Manchester, 5th Floor, Research St Mary's Hospital, Oxford Road Manchester, M13 9WL, UK.
J Affect Disord. 2012 Dec 15;142(1-3):22-30. doi: 10.1016/j.jad.2012.04.027. Epub 2012 Sep 7.
We review intervention trials that have used the State-Trait Anxiety inventory (STAI) as a measure of maternal anxiety in pregnancy in order to provide ranges in scores before and after participation in complementary therapy-based interventions to highlight the expected ranges of scores in pregnancy and determine whether anxiety in pregnancy is amenable to change when measured by the STAI.
Combinations of the key words "STAI", "state anxiety", "pregnancy", "anxiety", "maternal", "stress", "outcome" and "intervention" were used to search publications between January 1970 and January 2011. Studies eligible for inclusion recruited low risk, adult women to a non-pharmacological intervention or a comparator group, and measured anxiety at baseline and post-intervention.
Ten studies were eligible. Scores were routinely high compared to expected ranges in non-pregnant populations. Studies examining the immediate effects of an intervention consistently reported significantly lowered STAI scores after a single session. Likewise, studies examining the effect of interventions consisting of multiple sessions over the course of pregnancy found that those in the intervention group were more likely to show an improvement in STAI scores.
Heterogeneity in type and duration of intervention prevent drawing conclusions on which were most effective in reducing anxiety.
Scores on the STAI appear amenable to change during pregnancy, both after a single session and multiple sessions of interventions designed to reduce maternal anxiety. This review offers a guideline for the expected range of scores for future studies examining the efficacy of interventions in pregnancy when using the STAI.
我们回顾了使用状态-特质焦虑量表(STAI)作为衡量妊娠期间产妇焦虑的指标的干预试验,以便提供在参与补充治疗为基础的干预之前和之后的分数范围,突出妊娠期间的预期分数范围,并确定STAI 测量时妊娠焦虑是否可以改变。
使用“STAI”、“状态焦虑”、“妊娠”、“焦虑”、“产妇”、“压力”、“结果”和“干预”等关键词的组合,搜索 1970 年 1 月至 2011 年 1 月期间的出版物。符合纳入条件的研究招募了低风险的成年女性参加非药物干预或对照组,并在基线和干预后测量焦虑。
有 10 项研究符合条件。与非妊娠人群的预期范围相比,分数通常较高。研究检查干预的即时效果时,一致报告单次治疗后 STAI 分数明显降低。同样,研究检查由多个疗程组成的干预对妊娠过程的影响发现,干预组的人更有可能改善 STAI 分数。
干预的类型和持续时间的异质性使得无法得出哪种干预最有效的结论,以减少焦虑。
STAI 的分数在妊娠期间似乎是可以改变的,无论是单次治疗后还是为减少产妇焦虑而设计的多次治疗后。这篇综述为未来使用 STAI 研究干预措施在妊娠中的疗效时提供了一个预期分数范围的指南。