Annweiler Cédric, Herrmann François R, Fantino Bruno, Brugg Bernard, Beauchet Olivier
Department of Neuroscience, Division of Geriatric Medicine, Angers University Hospital, Angers, France.
Cogn Behav Neurol. 2012 Sep;25(3):121-7. doi: 10.1097/WNN.0b013e31826df647.
To determine whether treatment with memantine plus vitamin D is more effective than memantine or vitamin D alone in improving cognition among patients with Alzheimer disease (AD).
We studied 43 white outpatients (mean 84.7 ± 6.3 years; 65.1% women) with a new diagnosis of AD, who had not taken anti-dementia drugs or vitamin D supplements. We prescribed memantine alone (n = 18), vitamin D alone (n = 17), or memantine plus vitamin D (n = 8) for an average of 6 months. We assessed cognitive change with the Mini-Mental State Examination (MMSE). We used age, sex, pre-treatment MMSE score, and duration of treatment as covariables.
Before treatment, the 3 groups had comparable MMSE scores. At 6 months, participants taking memantine plus vitamin D increased their MMSE score by 4.0 ± 3.7 points (P = 0.034), while participants taking memantine alone remained stable (change of 0.0 ± 1.8 points; P = 0.891), as did those taking vitamin D alone (-0.6 ± 3.1 points; P = 0.504). Treatment with memantine plus vitamin D was associated with improvement in the MMSE score compared to memantine or vitamin D alone after adjustment for covariables (P < 0.01). Mixed regression analysis showed that the visit by combined treatments (memantine plus vitamin D) interaction was significant (P = 0.001), while memantine or vitamin D alone showed no effect.
Patients with AD who took memantine plus vitamin D for 6 months had a statistically and clinically relevant gain in cognition, underlining possible synergistic and potentiating benefits of the combination.
确定美金刚与维生素D联合治疗在改善阿尔茨海默病(AD)患者认知功能方面是否比单独使用美金刚或维生素D更有效。
我们研究了43名新诊断为AD的白人门诊患者(平均年龄84.7±6.3岁;65.1%为女性),他们未服用抗痴呆药物或维生素D补充剂。我们分别为18名患者单独开具美金刚,17名患者单独开具维生素D,8名患者开具美金刚加维生素D,平均治疗6个月。我们使用简易精神状态检查表(MMSE)评估认知变化。我们将年龄、性别、治疗前MMSE评分和治疗持续时间作为协变量。
治疗前,三组的MMSE评分相当。6个月时,服用美金刚加维生素D的参与者MMSE评分提高了4.0±3.7分(P = 0.034),而单独服用美金刚的参与者评分保持稳定(变化0.0±1.8分;P = 0.891),单独服用维生素D的参与者也是如此(-0.6±3.1分;P = 0.504)。在对协变量进行调整后,与单独使用美金刚或维生素D相比,美金刚加维生素D治疗与MMSE评分改善相关(P < 0.01)。混合回归分析显示,联合治疗(美金刚加维生素D)的访视交互作用显著(P = 0.001),而单独使用美金刚或维生素D则无效果。
服用美金刚加维生素D 6个月的AD患者在认知方面有统计学和临床意义上的改善,突显了联合治疗可能存在的协同增效益处。