Adamu A N, Abiola A O, Ibrahim Mto
Department of Obstetrics and Gynecology, Federal Medical Center, Birnin-Kebbi, Kebbi State, Nigeria.
Niger J Clin Pract. 2012 Jul-Sep;15(3):326-32. doi: 10.4103/1119-3077.100632.
The Routine Pap smear test has successfully reduced the incidence of invasive cervical cancer in the presence of a proper structure for its implementation. This study was designed to assess the effect of health education on the knowledge, attitude, and uptake of Pap smear among female teachers.
It was a quasi-experimental, controlled study with a pre-test, post-test design. A total of 100 respondents were recruited for each of the intervention and control groups, by the multistage sampling technique.
The mean knowledge score of cervical cancer was low in both the interventions (25.5% ± 10.5) and control groups (18.9% ± 10.0) at baseline; a significant rise to 57.2% ± 20.7 was recorded after the intervention in the Intervention group (P<0.0001). The baseline mean attitude score was also low in the intervention and control groups (17.1% ± 6.3 and 14.1% ± 6.4, respectively); post intervention there was a significant rise of up to 28.0% ± 12.8 in the Intervention group (P<0.0001). The proportion of respondents with a reported practice of Pap smear was low and similar in both the groups at baseline (1.1 and 4.9% in the intervention and control groups, respectively, P=0.16). Uptake of free Pap smear was poor at the post-intervention phase in both the groups (P=0.45). Reported reasons for poor uptake included the respondents' dislike for the test (38.4%) and the belief that the test was not necessary (24.4%). About 20% of the respondents did not have any reason at all.
Health education had no significant effect on the uptake of a free Pap smear among teachers. Despite the significant improvement in the attitude toward the test, many respondents did not like the test after than before the intervention. Sociocultural issues such as the gender of the sample collector, and system factors like few service delivery points, and the time required to access the service could have contributed to the poor uptake recorded in this study. A program designed to improve routine cervical cancer screening by Pap smear should therefore address not only the knowledge and cost, but also the sociocultural and systemic factors.
在具备适当实施结构的情况下,常规巴氏涂片检查已成功降低了浸润性宫颈癌的发病率。本研究旨在评估健康教育对女教师巴氏涂片检查知识、态度和接受情况的影响。
这是一项采用前测、后测设计的准实验性对照研究。通过多阶段抽样技术,为干预组和对照组各招募了100名受访者。
基线时,干预组(25.5%±10.5)和对照组(18.9%±10.0)宫颈癌的平均知识得分均较低;干预组干预后显著提高至57.2%±20.7(P<0.0001)。干预组和对照组的基线平均态度得分也较低(分别为17.1%±6.3和14.1%±6.4);干预后,干预组显著提高至28.0%±12.8(P<0.0001)。报告进行巴氏涂片检查的受访者比例在基线时较低且两组相似(干预组和对照组分别为1.1%和4.9%,P=0.16)。两组在干预后阶段免费巴氏涂片检查的接受情况都很差(P=0.45)。报告的接受情况差的原因包括受访者不喜欢该检查(38.4%)以及认为该检查不必要(24.4%)。约20%的受访者根本没有任何理由。
健康教育对教师接受免费巴氏涂片检查没有显著影响。尽管对该检查的态度有显著改善,但许多受访者在干预后比干预前更不喜欢该检查。样本采集者的性别等社会文化问题以及服务提供点少、获取服务所需时间等系统因素可能导致了本研究中记录的接受情况差。因此,旨在通过巴氏涂片检查改善常规宫颈癌筛查的项目不仅应解决知识和成本问题,还应解决社会文化和系统因素。