Zhang Jia-ping, Xiang Fei, Tong Da-li, Luo Qi-zhi, Yuan Zhi-qiang, Yan Hong, Li Xiao-lu, Chen Jian, Peng Dai-zhi, Luo Gao-xing, Peng Yi-zhi, Huang Yue-sheng, Wu Jun
State Key Laboratory of Trauma, Burns and Combined Injury, Institute of Burn Research, Southwest Hospital, the Third Military Medical University, Chongqing 400038, China.
Zhonghua Shao Shang Za Zhi. 2012 Jun;28(3):165-9.
To retrospectively analyze the effect of restrictive fluid management strategy (RFMS) on the early pulmonary function and the prognosis of patients with extremely severe and extensive burn.
Thirteen patients with extremely severe burn hospitalized from June 2010 to November 2011, being treated with RFMS in the fluid reabsorption stage, were enrolled as treatment group. Twenty-six patients with extremely severe burn hospitalized from March 2008 to November 2011, being treated with normal fluid therapy in the fluid reabsorption stage, were enrolled as control group. The match proportion between treatment group and control group was 1:2. Fluid intake, fluid output, fluid balance (the difference between fluid intake and output), and plasma albumin level from post burn day (PBD) 3 to 10, pulmonary oxygenation index on PBD 3, 5, 7, 10, and 14, occurrence of lung and blood stream infections from PBD 7 to 14, and occurrence of acute respiratory distress syndrome (ARDS), occurrence of other organ complications, and mortality within 2 weeks post burn (PBW) were recorded and compared. Measurement data were processed with t test and randomized blocks analysis of variance, enumeration data were processed with Fisher's exact test.
Daily fluid intake of patients showed a tendency of decrease in both groups from PBD 3 to 10. Except for that of PBD 4, there was no statistically significant difference between two groups in fluid intake (with F values from 0.072 to 1.939, P values all above 0.05). Daily fluid output of patients showed a tendency of increase in both groups from PBD 3 to 10. It peaked on PBD 10 in control group and PBD 6 in treatment group. The mean daily fluid output was higher in treatment group than in control group from PBD 4 to 9, but without statistically significant difference (with F values from 0.001 to 3.026, P values all above 0.05). Fluid balance lowered in both groups, and it was the lowest on PBD 10 in control group and PBD 6 in treatment group. Fluid balance was lower in treatment group than in control group from PBD 3 to 7, and it showed statistically significant differences on PBD 4, 5, and 6 (with F values from 4.799 to 8.031, P values below 0.05). Plasma albumin level was higher in treatment group than in control group from PBD 3 to 10, with statistically significant differences observed on PBD 4, 9, and 10 (with F values from 5.691 to 10.551, P < 0.05 or P < 0.01). Pulmonary oxygenation index was higher in treatment group than in control group from PBD 3 to 14, with statistically significant differences observed on PBD 7 (respectively 372 ± 78 in treatment group and 291 ± 92 in control group, F = 5.184, P < 0.05) and 14 (respectively 354 ± 39 in treatment group and 283 ± 72 in control group, F = 8.683, P < 0.05). Lung infection and blood stream infection were respectively observed in 1 and 4 patient (s) in treatment group, and 9 and 11 patients in control group from PBD 7 to 14. Occurrence of ARDS, occurrence of other organ complications, and mortality were fewer in treatment group than in control group within PBW 2, though the differences were not statistically significant (P values all above 0.05).
RFMS is a useful strategy in improving early pulmonary oxygenation of patients with extremely severe and extensive burn by promoting the process of fluid reabsorption and rebalance. This strategy may be also beneficial for the prevention of organ complications as well as a better prognosis in severely burned patients.
回顾性分析限制性液体管理策略(RFMS)对特重度大面积烧伤患者早期肺功能及预后的影响。
选取2010年6月至2011年11月住院治疗的13例特重度烧伤患者作为治疗组,在液体复苏阶段采用RFMS治疗。选取2008年3月至2011年11月住院治疗的26例特重度烧伤患者作为对照组,在液体复苏阶段采用常规液体疗法治疗。治疗组与对照组的匹配比例为1∶2。记录并比较烧伤后第3天至第10天的液体入量、液体出量、液体平衡(液体入量与出量之差)及血浆白蛋白水平,烧伤后第3天、第5天、第7天、第10天和第14天的肺氧合指数,烧伤后第7天至第14天肺部及血流感染的发生情况,以及急性呼吸窘迫综合征(ARDS)的发生情况、其他器官并发症的发生情况和烧伤后2周内的死亡率。计量资料采用t检验和随机区组方差分析,计数资料采用Fisher确切概率法检验。
两组患者每日液体入量从烧伤后第3天至第10天均呈下降趋势。除烧伤后第4天外,两组患者的液体入量差异无统计学意义(F值为0.072~1.939,P值均大于0.05)。两组患者每日液体出量从烧伤后第