Department of Obstetrics and Gynecology, The University of Chicago, Chicago, IL, USA.
J Urban Health. 2013 Aug;90(4):586-601. doi: 10.1007/s11524-012-9764-9.
Secondary data sources are widely used to measure the built asset environment, although their validity for this purpose is not well-established. Using community-engaged research methodology, this study conducted a census of public-facing, built assets via direct observation and then tested the performance of these data against widely used secondary datasets. After engaging community organizations, a community education campaign was implemented. Using web-enabled cell phones and a web-based application prepopulated with the secondary data, census workers verified, modified, and/or added assets using street-level observation, supplementing data with web searches and telephone calls. Data were uploaded to http://www.SouthSideHealth.org . Using direct observation as the criterion standard, the sensitivity of secondary datasets was calculated. Of 5,773 assets on the prepopulated list, direct observation of public-facing assets verified 1,612 as operating; another 653 operating assets were newly identified. Sensitivity of the commercial list for nonresidential, operating assets was 61 %. Using the asset census as the criterion standard, secondary datasets were incomplete and inaccurate. Comprehensive, accurate built asset data are needed to advance urban health research, inform policy, and improve individuals' access to assets.
二手资料被广泛用于测量建成环境,尽管其在这方面的有效性尚未得到充分证实。本研究采用社区参与式研究方法,通过直接观察对面向公众的建成资产进行普查,然后测试这些数据与广泛使用的二手数据集的吻合程度。在与社区组织合作后,实施了一项社区教育活动。普查员使用具有上网功能的手机和预先填充有二手数据的网络应用程序,通过街道层面的观察核实、修改和/或添加资产,并通过网络搜索和电话补充数据。数据上传至 http://www.SouthSideHealth.org 。以直接观察作为判断标准,计算了二手数据集的敏感性。在预填列单上的 5773 个资产中,直接观察到 1612 个面向公众的资产在运行;另外还有 653 个正在运行的资产被新识别出来。商业清单对非住宅、运行中的资产的敏感性为 61%。以资产普查作为判断标准,二手数据集是不完整和不准确的。需要全面、准确的建成资产数据来推进城市健康研究、为政策提供信息并改善个人对资产的获取。