Tomko Rachel L, Brown Whitney C, Tragesser Sarah L, Wood Phillip K, Mehl Matthias R, Trull Timothy J
J Pers Disord. 2014 Jun;28(3):434-48. doi: 10.1521/pedi_2012_26_064. Epub 2012 Sep 17.
Anger and affective instability are key features of borderline personality disorder (BPD). Given the dynamic nature of affect, it is ideally studied using ambulatory assessment (AA). Recently, several major studies have examined affective instability via momentary self-report, using electronic diaries, which participants can use throughout their daily routine. The present study sought to complement this research by using an unobtrusive naturalistic observation method, the Electronically Activated Recorder (EAR). The EAR, which captures interpersonal behavior by periodically recording 50-second snippets of ambient sounds, was worn by 25 participants with BPD who also met the specific affective instability (AI) criterion as well as 13 participants with a depressive disorder (who did not meet criteria for AI or BPD) for three days. Trained coders listened to the captured recordings and rated participants' affect during each 50-second clip (i.e., in naturally varying social contexts). Results suggested that there were differences between diagnostic groups regarding the social context of anger, such that anger at a previous time interval predicted spending time alone in the subsequent time interval for the depressed group, but not for the BPD group. As an ambulatory observational method, the EAR offers an alternative to self-report and can provide insight into the naturalistic expression of emotions in BPD.
愤怒和情感不稳定是边缘型人格障碍(BPD)的关键特征。鉴于情感的动态性质,理想的研究方法是使用动态评估(AA)。最近,几项主要研究通过使用电子日记进行即时自我报告来研究情感不稳定,参与者可以在日常生活中随时使用电子日记。本研究试图通过使用一种不引人注意的自然观察方法——电子激活记录器(EAR)来补充这项研究。25名符合特定情感不稳定(AI)标准的BPD患者以及13名患有抑郁症(不符合AI或BPD标准)的参与者佩戴EAR三天,EAR通过定期录制50秒的周围环境声音片段来捕捉人际行为。经过培训的编码人员听取捕捉到的录音,并对每个50秒片段(即在自然变化的社会环境中)参与者的情感进行评分。结果表明,在愤怒的社会背景方面,诊断组之间存在差异,即前一个时间间隔的愤怒预测抑郁组在随后的时间间隔会独自待着,但BPD组则不然。作为一种动态观察方法,EAR为自我报告提供了一种替代方法,并可以深入了解BPD中情绪的自然表达。