Population Health Research Institute, McMaster University,Hamilton, Ontario, Canada.
Thromb Haemost. 2012 Dec;108(6):1228-35. doi: 10.1160/TH12-06-0433. Epub 2012 Sep 26.
Excellent control of the international normalised ratio (INR) is associated with improved clinical outcomes in patients receiving warfarin, and can be achieved by anticoagulation clinics but is difficult in general practice. Anticoagulation clinics have often used validated commercial computer systems to manage the INR, but these are not usually available to general practitioners. It was the objective of this study to perform a randomised trial of a simple one-step warfarin dosing algorithm against a widely used computerised dosing system. During the period of introduction of a commercial computerised warfarin dosing system (DAWN AC) to an anticoagulation clinic, patients were randomised to have warfarin dose adjustment done according to recommendations of the existing warfarin dosing algorithm or to those of the computerised system. The study tested if the computerised system was non-inferior to the existing algorithm for the primary outcome of time in therapeutic INR range of 2.0-3.0 (TTR), with a one-sided non-inferiority margin of 4.5%. There were 541 patients randomised to commercial computerised system and 527 to the algorithm. Median follow-up was 159 days. A dose recommendation was provided and followed in 91% of occasions for the computerised system and in 90% for the algorithm (p=0.03). The mean TTR was 71.0% (standard deviation [SD] 23.2) for the computerised system and 71.9% (SD 22.9) for the algorithm (difference 0.9% [95% confidence interval: -1.4% to 4.1%]; p-value for non-inferiority=0.002; p-value for superiority=0.34). In conclusion, similar maintenance control of the INR was achieved with a simple one-step dosing algorithm and a commercial computerised management system.
国际标准化比值(INR)的良好控制与接受华法林治疗的患者的临床结局改善相关,通过抗凝门诊可以实现这一点,但在一般实践中较为困难。抗凝门诊通常使用经过验证的商业计算机系统来管理 INR,但这些系统通常不适用于全科医生。本研究的目的是对一种简单的一步法华法林给药算法与广泛使用的计算机给药系统进行随机试验。在向抗凝门诊引入商业计算机化华法林给药系统(DAWN AC)期间,将患者随机分配,根据现有华法林给药算法或计算机系统的建议来调整华法林剂量。该研究检验了计算机系统在治疗 INR 范围 2.0-3.0(TTR)的主要结局方面是否不劣于现有算法,单侧非劣效性边界为 4.5%。有 541 名患者被随机分配至计算机化系统组,527 名患者被分配至算法组。中位随访时间为 159 天。对于计算机系统,有 91%的情况下提供并遵循了剂量建议,对于算法,有 90%的情况下提供并遵循了剂量建议(p=0.03)。计算机系统的平均 TTR 为 71.0%(标准差[SD] 23.2),算法的平均 TTR 为 71.9%(SD 22.9)(差值 0.9%[95%置信区间:-1.4%至 4.1%];非劣效性 p 值=0.002;优效性 p 值=0.34)。总之,使用简单的一步法给药算法和商业计算机化管理系统可以实现 INR 的相似维持控制。