Laboratory of Food Biotechnology, Institute of Food, Nutrition and Health, ETH Zurich, 8092 Zurich, Switzerland.
Int J Food Microbiol. 2012 Oct 1;159(2):74-83. doi: 10.1016/j.ijfoodmicro.2012.07.025. Epub 2012 Aug 2.
To provide new meat starter strains lacking antibiotic (AB) resistances, we explored the AB susceptibility in 116 coagulase-negative Staphylococcus (CNS) isolates from traditionally fermented sausages (n=40) manufactured with meat from conventional animal breeding, and from meat products (n=76) made from meat of animals raised in natural habitats under low- or no-antibiotic pressure. Less than 50% of these CNS isolates showed phenotypic resistances to at least one antibiotic (AB) by using microdilution assay. Resistances to penicillins and tetracycline were most often observed and could be traced back to blaZ and tet(K) genes. Prevalence of AB resistances was species-dependent and mainly found in isolates of Staphylococcus warneri (78%), Staphylococcus capitis (75%) and Staphylococcus epidermidis (67%), but only sporadically detected in Staphylococcus carnosus (27%) and Staphylococcus equorum (18%). AB resistances were more often observed in S. xylosus isolates originating from natural habitats compared to traditionally fermented sausages made from conventional meat. A selection of 101 isolates belonging to S. xylosus (n=63), S. carnosus (n=21) and S. equorum (n=17) were subsequently grouped by pulsed-field gel electrophoresis (PFGE) into strain clusters. No S. carnosus and only five S. xylosus strains were lacking AB resistances and exhibited a PFGE genotype different from commercial starters. These strains, together with 17 S. equorum strains, were further studied for safety and technological characteristics. The ability to produce biogenic amines was not detected in any strain. PCR amplifications for enterotoxin encoding genes seg-sej were detected in one, and for δ-hemolysin encoding gene hld in four S. equorum strains, but phenotypic hemolytic activity was visible for three S. xylosus and 15 S. equorum strains. Catalase and nitrate reductase activity was observed in all isolates tested; particularly S. equorum showed high nitrate reduction. In conclusion, we were able to select four new meat starter strains (two S. xylosus and two S. equorum strains) out of 116 investigated CNS, fulfilling all safety criteria including the absence of AB resistances, production of biogenic amines and genes encoding virulence factors but exhibiting high nitrate reductase and catalase activity as suitable technological characteristics. Thus, S. equorum isolates, often the dominant species in spontaneously fermented meat products, provided a prospective meat starter species exhibiting high nitrate reduction and low prevalence of AB resistances.
为了提供缺乏抗生素(AB)抗性的新型肉用发酵剂菌株,我们探索了 116 株凝固酶阴性葡萄球菌(CNS)的 AB 敏感性,这些菌株分别来自传统发酵香肠(n=40)和来自低抗生素或无抗生素压力下天然栖息地饲养的动物的肉类制成的肉类产品(n=76)。使用微量稀释法,不到 50%的这些 CNS 分离株对至少一种抗生素(AB)表现出表型抗性。最常观察到对青霉素和四环素的抗性,并可追溯到 blaZ 和 tet(K)基因。AB 抗性具有种依赖性,主要存在于 Warneri 葡萄球菌(78%)、Capitis 葡萄球菌(75%)和 Epidermidis 葡萄球菌(67%)的分离株中,但在 Carnosus 葡萄球菌(27%)和 Equorum 葡萄球菌(18%)的分离株中仅偶尔发现。与传统发酵香肠相比,源自天然栖息地的 S. xylosus 分离株中更常观察到 AB 抗性。随后,根据脉冲场凝胶电泳(PFGE)将属于 S. xylosus(n=63)、S. carnosus(n=21)和 S. equorum(n=17)的 101 株分离株分为菌株群。没有发现 Carnosus 葡萄球菌,只有 5 株 S. xylosus 菌株缺乏 AB 抗性,并且表现出与商业发酵剂不同的 PFGE 基因型。这些菌株与 17 株 S. equorum 菌株一起进一步研究了安全性和技术特性。未在任何菌株中检测到生物胺的产生能力。在 1 株 S. equorum 菌株中检测到编码 seg-sej 肠毒素的基因,在 4 株 S. equorum 菌株中检测到编码 δ-溶血素的基因 hld,但在 3 株 S. xylosus 和 15 株 S. equorum 菌株中可见表型溶血活性。所有测试的分离株均表现出过氧化氢酶和硝酸盐还原酶活性;特别是 S. equorum 表现出高硝酸盐还原能力。总之,我们能够从 116 株 CNS 中选择 4 株新型肉用发酵剂菌株(2 株 S. xylosus 和 2 株 S. equorum 菌株),这些菌株符合所有安全性标准,包括缺乏 AB 抗性、生物胺产生和编码毒力因子的基因,但表现出高硝酸盐还原酶和过氧化氢酶活性,作为合适的技术特性。因此,经常在自发发酵肉类产品中占主导地位的 Equorum 分离株提供了一种有前景的肉类发酵剂,具有高硝酸盐还原能力和低 AB 抗性流行率。