Cassano-Piché A, Fan M, Sabovitch S, Masino C, Easty A C
Ont Health Technol Assess Ser. 2012;12(16):1-132. Epub 2012 May 1.
Minimal research has been conducted into the potential patient safety issues related to administering multiple intravenous (IV) infusions to a single patient. Previous research has highlighted that there are a number of related safety risks. In Phase 1a of this study, an analysis of 2 national incident-reporting databases (Institute for Safe Medical Practices Canada and United States Food and Drug Administration MAUDE) found that a high percentage of incidents associated with the administration of multiple IV infusions resulted in patient harm.
The primary objectives of Phase 1b of this study were to identify safety issues with the potential to cause patient harm stemming from the administration of multiple IV infusions; and to identify how nurses are being educated on key principles required to safely administer multiple IV infusions.
A field study was conducted at 12 hospital clinical units (sites) across Ontario, and telephone interviews were conducted with program coordinators or instructors from both the Ontario baccalaureate nursing degree programs and the Ontario postgraduate Critical Care Nursing Certificate programs. Data were analyzed using Rasmussen's 1997 Risk Management Framework and a Health Care Failure Modes and Effects Analysis.
Twenty-two primary patient safety issues were identified with the potential to directly cause patient harm. Seventeen of these (critical issues) were categorized into 6 themes. A cause-consequence tree was established to outline all possible contributing factors for each critical issue. Clinical recommendations were identified for immediate distribution to, and implementation by, Ontario hospitals. Future investigation efforts were planned for Phase 2 of the study.
This exploratory field study identifies the potential for errors, but does not describe the direct observation of such errors, except in a few cases where errors were observed. Not all issues are known in advance, and the frequency of errors is too low to be observed in the time allotted and with the limited sample of observations.
The administration of multiple IV infusions to a single patient is a complex task with many potential associated patient safety risks. Improvements to infusion and infusion-related technology, education standards, clinical best practice guidelines, hospital policies, and unit work practices are required to reduce the risk potential. This report makes several recommendations to Ontario hospitals so that they can develop an awareness of the issues highlighted in this report and minimize some of the risks. Further investigation of mitigating strategies is required and will be undertaken in Phase 2 of this research.
针对给单一患者进行多种静脉输液可能涉及的患者安全问题,所开展的研究极少。先前的研究已强调存在若干相关安全风险。在本研究的1a阶段,对两个国家事件报告数据库(加拿大安全医疗实践协会和美国食品药品监督管理局医疗产品不良事件数据库)进行分析后发现,与多种静脉输液给药相关的事件中,有很大比例导致了患者伤害。
本研究1b阶段的主要目标是确定因多种静脉输液给药而可能导致患者伤害的安全问题;并确定护士是如何接受关于安全进行多种静脉输液所需关键原则的教育的。
在安大略省的12个医院临床科室(地点)开展了一项实地研究,并对安大略省本科护理学位项目以及安大略省研究生重症护理证书项目的项目协调员或教员进行了电话访谈。使用拉斯穆森1997年的风险管理框架和医疗保健失效模式与效应分析对数据进行了分析。
确定了22个可能直接导致患者伤害的主要患者安全问题。其中17个(关键问题)被归为6个主题。建立了因果关系树以概述每个关键问题的所有可能促成因素。确定了临床建议以便立即分发给安大略省各医院并由其实施。为该研究的第2阶段规划了未来的调查工作。
这项探索性实地研究确定了出错的可能性,但除了少数观察到错误的情况外,并未描述对这些错误的直接观察。并非所有问题都能预先知晓,而且错误发生频率过低,无法在规定时间内以及有限的观察样本中被观察到。
给单一患者进行多种静脉输液是一项复杂任务,存在许多潜在的相关患者安全风险。需要改进输液及与输液相关的技术、教育标准、临床最佳实践指南、医院政策和科室工作流程,以降低潜在风险。本报告向安大略省各医院提出了若干建议,以便它们能够认识到本报告所强调的问题,并将一些风险降至最低。需要对缓解策略进行进一步调查,并将在本研究的第2阶段开展此项工作。