Masters Joan
Bellarmine University, Louisville, KY, USA.
J Psychosoc Nurs Ment Health Serv. 2012 Oct;50(10):38-45. doi: 10.3928/02793695-20120907-99.
Memoirs can be more interesting to read than textbooks and are frequently just as informative. Many people have written excellent memoirs about their own or family member's psychiatric illness. However, psychiatric practitioner memoirs have the advantage of showing how an enthusiastic but novice clinician develops into a skilled practitioner, something students are usually eager to understand. Twenty-nine memoirs by psychiatric practitioners (nurses, advanced practice nurses, psychiatrists, and psychologists) were reviewed and critiqued for clinical accuracy and relevancy, positive role-modeling, advocacy, a promotion of a positive image of nursing, and suitability for use in teaching undergraduate nursing students; of these, 3 are outstanding books written by nurses ( The Comfort Garden: Tales from the Trauma Unit by Barkin and Tales from the page Chronicles and The Pager Chronicles Volume Two by Rancour) and one by psychiatrist(Psychward by Seager). An annotated bibliography of all practitioner memoirs reviewed is provided.
回忆录可能比教科书更有趣,而且往往同样具有信息价值。许多人撰写了关于自己或家庭成员精神疾病的优秀回忆录。然而,精神科从业者的回忆录具有这样的优势,即展示一位热情但新手的临床医生如何成长为一名熟练的从业者,这是学生们通常渴望了解的。我们对29篇精神科从业者(护士、高级实践护士、精神科医生和心理学家)的回忆录进行了审查,并就临床准确性和相关性、积极的榜样作用、倡导、提升护理的正面形象以及是否适合用于本科护理学生教学等方面进行了评判;其中,有3本是护士撰写的杰出书籍(巴金所著的《安慰花园:创伤科的故事》以及兰库尔所著的《书页编年史故事集》和《传呼机编年史第二卷》),还有一本是精神科医生撰写的(西格所著的《精神病区》)。本文提供了所有被审查的从业者回忆录的注释书目。