Vameghi R, Mohammad K, Karimloo M, Soleimani F, Sajedi F
Pediatric Neurorehabilitation Research Center, University of Social Welfare and Rehabilitation Sciences, Tehran, Iran.
Iran J Public Health. 2010;39(2):77-88. Epub 2010 Jun 30.
The aim of the study was to compare the effects of 'face-to-face education' and 'educational movies' on 'knowledge' and 'practice' of women of child-bearing-age, in terms of health-care during pregnancy and during infancy in a suburban region near Tehran City, Iran.
In this quasi-experimental study, the sample included 873 married women. Questionnaires for knowledge and practice assessment were designed. The women were assigned to three groups: control (group I), face-to-face education (group II), and educational movie (group III). Knowledge questionnaires were completed before and immediately after intervention. Practice questionnaires were completed before and three months after intervention. Both questionnaires consisted of two types of questions: type A (concerning infant care issues) and type B (concerning prenatal health care).
There was a significant difference in post-test knowledge between groups I and II and between groups I and III, but not between groups II and III. In terms of post-test practice, the changes were determined for every individual question, and significantly, better results were seen in group II, especially concerning type B questions.
Face to face education lead to better practice than educational movies. In addition, significantly better practice occurred regarding child health care issues rather than prenatal issues in both groups. Realistic and tangible issues, those easy to practice, and with little or no economical burden imposed on the family, progressed from the knowledge state to the practice state more successfully in both groups.
本研究旨在比较“面对面教育”和“教育影片”对伊朗德黑兰市附近郊区育龄妇女在孕期和婴儿期保健方面的“知识”和“实践”的影响。
在这项准实验研究中,样本包括873名已婚妇女。设计了知识和实践评估问卷。这些妇女被分为三组:对照组(第一组)、面对面教育组(第二组)和教育影片组(第三组)。知识问卷在干预前和干预后立即完成。实践问卷在干预前和干预后三个月完成。两份问卷均由两种类型的问题组成:A类(关于婴儿护理问题)和B类(关于产前保健)。
第一组和第二组之间以及第一组和第三组之间在测试后知识方面存在显著差异,但第二组和第三组之间没有。在测试后实践方面,对每个单独问题的变化进行了测定,显著地,第二组取得了更好的结果,尤其是在B类问题上。
面对面教育比教育影片能带来更好的实践效果。此外,两组在儿童保健问题上的实践效果明显优于产前问题。现实且具体的问题,即易于实践且对家庭造成的经济负担很小或没有经济负担的问题,在两组中从知识状态到实践状态的进展更为成功。