Shively E H, Wieman T J, Adams A L, Romines R B, Garrison R N
Department of Surgery, University of Louisville School of Medicine, Kentucky 40292.
Am J Surg. 1990 Apr;159(4):380-4; discussion 385. doi: 10.1016/s0002-9610(05)81276-0.
The value of operative cholangiography in the management of biliary tract disease has been questioned. To better define the role of cholangiography, we reviewed 579 consecutive cholecystectomies done by 1 group of surgeons in a small rural practice over 8 years. Cholangiography demonstrated unsuspected common bile duct disease in 5% of the procedures, while 12% of the patients were spared an unnecessary choledochotomy after a normal cholangiogram was obtained. There was no morbidity, mortality, or prolongation of the hospital stay attributed to the cholangiographic procedure. These findings bolster the argument for routine cholangiography as a safe, effective, and helpful screening examination for patients who are at risk for having common bile duct disease.
术中胆管造影在胆道疾病治疗中的价值一直受到质疑。为了更好地明确胆管造影的作用,我们回顾了一组外科医生在一个小型乡村诊所8年间连续进行的579例胆囊切除术。胆管造影在5%的手术中显示出未被怀疑的胆总管疾病,而在获得正常胆管造影结果后,12%的患者避免了不必要的胆总管切开术。未发现因胆管造影检查导致的发病率、死亡率或住院时间延长。这些发现支持了将常规胆管造影作为对有胆总管疾病风险患者进行安全、有效且有用的筛查检查的观点。