Department of Experimental Medical Science, Lund University, Lund, Sweden.
Hum Mutat. 2013 Feb;34(2):275-82. doi: 10.1002/humu.22253. Epub 2013 Jan 18.
Computational prediction methods are widely used for the analysis of human genome sequence variants and their effects on gene/protein function, splice site aberration, pathogenicity, and disease risk. New methods are frequently developed. We believe that guidelines are essential for those writing articles about new prediction methods, as well as for those applying these tools in their research, so that the necessary details are reported. This will enable readers to gain the full picture of technical information, performance, and interpretation of results, and to facilitate comparisons of related methods. Here, we provide instructions on how to describe new methods, report datasets, and assess the performance of predictive tools. We also discuss what details of predictor implementation are essential for authors to understand. Similarly, these guidelines for the use of predictors provide instructions on what needs to be delineated in the text, as well as how researchers can avoid unwarranted conclusions. They are applicable to most prediction methods currently utilized. By applying these guidelines, authors will help reviewers, editors, and readers to more fully comprehend prediction methods and their use.
计算预测方法被广泛用于分析人类基因组序列变异及其对基因/蛋白质功能、剪接位点异常、致病性和疾病风险的影响。新的方法经常被开发出来。我们认为,对于撰写有关新预测方法的文章的作者以及在研究中应用这些工具的作者来说,指南是必不可少的,以便报告必要的细节。这将使读者能够全面了解技术信息、性能和结果的解释,并促进相关方法的比较。在这里,我们提供了如何描述新方法、报告数据集和评估预测工具性能的说明。我们还讨论了预测器实现的哪些细节对于作者来说是必不可少的。同样,这些预测器使用指南为文本中需要划定的内容以及研究人员如何避免得出不合理的结论提供了说明。它们适用于目前使用的大多数预测方法。通过应用这些指南,作者将帮助审稿人、编辑和读者更全面地理解预测方法及其应用。