Keegan Denise, McDermott Edel, Byrne Kathryn, Moloney David, Doherty Glen A, Mulcahy Hugh E
Department of Gastroenterology, Centre for Colorectal Disease, St Vincent's University Hospital/University College Dublin, Elm Park, Dublin, Ireland.
Scand J Gastroenterol. 2013 Feb;48(2):183-8. doi: 10.3109/00365521.2012.744090. Epub 2012 Nov 27.
Only two inflammatory bowel disease (IBD) knowledge scales are available, both primarily aimed at evaluating the effectiveness of clinical education programs. The aim of this study was to develop and validate a short knowledge questionnaire for clinical and academic research purposes.
Following initial development, the questionnaire was tested on junior doctors, nurses and administrative staff to assess validity. The questionnaire was then assessed and compared with a previous questionnaire in 31 IBD patients. Three hundred and three further patients completed the questionnaire to establish reliability and determine factors independently associated with disease-related knowledge.
Doctors answered more questions correctly than nurses who scored better than administrative staff (p < 0.001). There was a fair correlation in scores between the short knowledge questionnaire and a previously validated long survey (r = 0.488; p = 0.005). The short knowledge questionnaire was quicker to complete (p < 0.001), was rated as less difficult to understand (p = 0.004) and induce less anxiety (p = 0.004). Both questionnaires were rated similarly with regard to relevance (p = 0.71). Internal consistency was demonstrated with a Cronbach's alpha of 0.73. In clinical testing on 301 patients, the final multivariate model identified young age, Crohn's disease, higher educational status and the presence of a first-degree family member with IBD as being independently and significantly associated with disease-related knowledge.
The short knowledge questionnaire is a simple, valid, reliable and easy to understand research instrument for rapidly assessing knowledge in IBD patients.
目前仅有两种炎症性肠病(IBD)知识量表,二者主要用于评估临床教育项目的效果。本研究的目的是开发并验证一种用于临床和学术研究的简短知识问卷。
初步开发后,该问卷在初级医生、护士和行政人员中进行测试以评估效度。随后,对31例IBD患者的问卷进行评估并与之前的问卷作比较。另外303例患者完成该问卷以确定其信度并确定与疾病相关知识独立相关的因素。
医生回答正确的问题比护士多,护士的得分高于行政人员(p<0.001)。简短知识问卷与之前验证过的长调查问卷之间的得分存在中度相关性(r = 0.488;p = 0.005)。简短知识问卷完成速度更快(p<0.001),被评为理解难度更低(p = 0.004)且引起的焦虑更少(p = 0.004)。两份问卷在相关性方面的评分相似(p = 0.71)。Cronbach's α系数为0.73,表明具有内部一致性。在对301例患者的临床测试中,最终的多变量模型确定年龄较小、克罗恩病、较高的教育程度以及有IBD一级家庭成员与疾病相关知识独立且显著相关。
简短知识问卷是一种简单、有效、可靠且易于理解的研究工具,可用于快速评估IBD患者的知识水平。