Department of Global Health, University of Washington, Seattle, WA 98105, USA.
Hum Resour Health. 2012 Nov 26;10:46. doi: 10.1186/1478-4491-10-46.
Oral health services are inadequate and unevenly distributed in many developing countries, particularly those in sub-Saharan Africa. Rural areas in these countries and poorer sections of the population in urban areas often do not have access to oral health services mainly because of a significant shortage of dentists and the high costs of care. We reviewed Cameroon's experience with deploying a mid-level cadre of oral health professionals and the feasibility of establishing a more formal and predictable role for these health workers. We anticipate that a task-shifting approach in the provision of dental care will significantly improve the uneven distribution of oral health services particularly in the rural areas of Cameroon, which is currently served by only 3% of the total number of dentists.
The setting of this study was the Cameroon Baptist Convention Health Board (BCHB), which has four dentists and 42 mid-level providers. De-identified data were collected manually from the registries of 10 Baptist Convention clinics located in six of Cameroon's 10 regions and then entered into an Excel format before importing into STATA. A retrospective abstraction of all entries for patient visits starting October 2010, and going back in time until 1500 visits were extracted from each clinic.
This study showed that mid-level providers in BCHB clinics are offering a full scope of dental work across the 10 clinics, with the exception of treatment for major facial injuries. Mid-level providers alone performed 93.5% of all extractions, 87.5% of all fillings, 96.5% of all root canals, 97.5% of all cleanings, and 98.1% of all dentures. The dentists also typically played a teaching role in training the mid-level providers.
The Ministry of Health in Cameroon has an opportunity to learn from the BCHB model to expand access to oral health care across the country. This study shows the benefits of using a simple, workable, low-cost way to provide needed dental services across Cameroon, particularly in rural areas.
在许多发展中国家,包括撒哈拉以南非洲国家,口腔卫生服务不足且分布不均。这些国家的农村地区和城市中较贫困的人群往往无法获得口腔卫生服务,主要原因是牙医严重短缺,且护理费用高昂。我们回顾了喀麦隆在部署中级口腔卫生专业人员方面的经验,以及为这些卫生工作者建立更正式和可预测角色的可行性。我们预计,在提供牙科护理方面进行任务转移的方法将极大地改善口腔卫生服务的分布不均状况,特别是在喀麦隆的农村地区,目前只有总牙医人数的 3%为这些地区提供服务。
本研究的地点是喀麦隆浸礼会公约健康委员会(BCHB),该委员会有 4 名牙医和 42 名中级提供者。从位于喀麦隆 10 个地区中的 6 个地区的 10 个浸礼会诊所登记册中手动收集去识别数据,然后将其输入 Excel 格式,再导入 STATA。从每个诊所提取 2010 年 10 月开始的所有患者就诊记录,回溯至 1500 次就诊,进行回顾性提取。
本研究表明,BCHB 诊所的中级提供者在 10 个诊所中提供了全面的牙科服务,除了治疗重大面部损伤。中级提供者单独完成了所有拔牙的 93.5%、所有填充的 87.5%、所有根管治疗的 96.5%、所有洁牙的 97.5%和所有义齿的 98.1%。牙医通常还在培训中级提供者方面发挥教学作用。
喀麦隆卫生部有机会从 BCHB 模式中吸取经验,在全国范围内扩大口腔卫生保健的可及性。本研究表明,采用简单、可行、低成本的方式在喀麦隆,特别是在农村地区提供所需的牙科服务具有诸多益处。