Woloszynski Tomasz, Podsiadlo Pawel, Stachowiak Gwidon, Kurzynski Marek
Tribology Laboratory, School of Mechanical and Chemical Engineering, The University of Western Australia, Perth, WA, Australia.
Proc Inst Mech Eng H. 2012 Nov;226(11):887-94. doi: 10.1177/0954411912456650.
There is a growing need for classification systems that can accurately detect and predict knee osteoarthritis (OA) from plain radiographs. For this purpose, a system based on a support vector machine (SVM) classifier and distances measured between trabecular bone (TB) texture images was developed and tested in previous work. Unlike other systems, it allows an image classification without the calculation and selection of numerous texture features, and it is invariant to a range of imaging conditions encountered in a routine X-ray screening of knees. Although the system exhibited 85.4% classification accuracy in OA detection, which was higher than those obtained from other systems, its performance could be further improved. To achieve this, a dissimilarity-based multiple classifier (DMC) system is developed in this study. The system measures distances between TB texture images and generates a diverse ensemble of classifiers using prototype selection, bootstrapping of training set and heterogeneous classifiers. A measure of competence is used to select accurate (i.e. better-than-random) classifiers from the ensemble, which are then combined through the majority voting rule. To evaluate the newly developed system in OA detection (prediction of OA progression), TB texture images selected on standardised radiographs of healthy and OA (non-progressive and progressive OA) knees were used. The results obtained showed that the DMC system has higher classification accuracies for the detection (90.51% with 87.65% specificity and 93.33% sensitivity) and prediction (80% with 82.00% specificity and 77.97% sensitivity) than other systems, indicating its potential as a decision-support tool for the assessment of radiographic knee OA.
对于能够从普通X线片准确检测和预测膝关节骨关节炎(OA)的分类系统的需求日益增长。为此,在先前的工作中开发并测试了一种基于支持向量机(SVM)分类器和小梁骨(TB)纹理图像间测量距离的系统。与其他系统不同,它无需计算和选择众多纹理特征即可进行图像分类,并且对于膝关节常规X线筛查中遇到的一系列成像条件具有不变性。尽管该系统在OA检测中表现出85.4%的分类准确率,高于其他系统,但仍可进一步提高其性能。为实现这一目标,本研究开发了一种基于差异的多分类器(DMC)系统。该系统测量TB纹理图像之间的距离,并使用原型选择、训练集自采样和异构分类器生成多样化的分类器集合。使用一种能力度量从集合中选择准确的(即优于随机的)分类器,然后通过多数投票规则将它们组合起来。为了评估新开发的系统在OA检测(OA进展预测)中的性能,使用了在健康和OA(非进展性和进展性OA)膝关节的标准化X线片上选择的TB纹理图像。所得结果表明,DMC系统在检测(准确率90.51%,特异性87.65%,灵敏度93.33%)和预测(准确率80%,特异性82.00%,灵敏度77.97%)方面比其他系统具有更高的分类准确率,表明其作为评估膝关节放射学OA的决策支持工具的潜力。