Université de Bordeaux, French National Reference Center for Campylobacters, 33076, Bordeaux, France.
Gut Pathog. 2012 Dec 4;4(1):17. doi: 10.1186/1757-4749-4-17.
The recently developed rapid immunochromatographic tests (ICT) have the potential to provide a quick and easy diagnosis of Campylobacter enteritis in comparison to culture. In a previous study we found them sensitive but lacking in specificity. The aim of the present study was to focus on the problem of specificity and determine the positive predictive value (PPV) of a positive result of the ImmunoCard Stat! Campy (Meridian Bioscience, Cincinnati, OH, USA). For this purpose, the stools positive by ICT were cultured according to 3 different protocols: Karmali agar, Preston enrichment broth subcultured on Karmali agar, and a filtration method on a blood agar without antibiotics, all incubated for 7 days at 37°C. Out of 609 stools from adults and children with community acquired enteritis, the reference methods detected 25 positive cases (4.1%) (culture: 19, specific PCR and ELISA both positive: 6) and the ICT: 31 including the 25 true positives. The PPV was 80.6%. We conclude that ICT is a good method to screen Campylobacter positive stools but because of its lack of specificity the positive stools must be tested by another method.
最近开发的快速免疫层析试验(ICT)有可能与培养相比,为弯曲菌肠炎的快速诊断提供便利。在之前的研究中,我们发现它们虽然灵敏,但特异性不足。本研究的目的是关注特异性问题,并确定 ImmunoCard Stat!Campy(Meridian Bioscience,辛辛那提,俄亥俄州,美国)阳性结果的阳性预测值(PPV)。为此,根据三种不同的方案对 ICT 阳性粪便进行培养:Karmali 琼脂、Preston 增菌肉汤在 Karmali 琼脂上亚培养,以及一种无抗生素的血液琼脂滤过法,所有培养物均在 37°C 下孵育 7 天。在来自成人和儿童社区获得性肠炎的 609 份粪便中,参考方法检测到 25 例阳性病例(4.1%)(培养:19 例,特异性 PCR 和 ELISA 均阳性:6 例)和 ICT:31 例,包括 25 例真阳性病例。PPV 为 80.6%。我们得出结论,ICT 是一种筛选弯曲菌阳性粪便的良好方法,但由于其特异性不足,阳性粪便必须用另一种方法进行检测。