South Asia Network for Chronic Disease (SANCD), Public Health Foundation of India (PHFI), C1/52, First Floor, Safdarjung Development Area, New Delhi 110 016, India.
BMC Public Health. 2012 Dec 5;12:1048. doi: 10.1186/1471-2458-12-1048.
High out-of-pocket-expenditure (OOPE) deters families from seeking skilled/institutional care. 'Janani Suraksha Yojana (JSY), a conditional cash transfer programme launched in 2005 to mitigate OOPE and to promote institutional deliveries among the poor, is part of Government of India's efforts to achieve Millennium Development Goals (MDGs) 4 and 5. The objective of this study is to estimate variations in OOPE for normal/caesarean-section deliveries, JSY-programme use and delivery associated borrowings - by states and union territories, and socio-demographic profiling of families, in India.
Secondary analysis of data from the District Level Household Survey (DLHS-3), 2007-08. Mean and median OOPE, percentage use of JSY and percentage of families needing to borrow money to pay for delivery associated expenditure was estimated for institutional and home deliveries.
Half (52%) of all deliveries in India occurred at home in 2007/08. OOPE for women having institutional deliveries remained high, with considerable variation between states and union territories. Mean OOPE (SD) of a normal delivery in public and private institution respectively in India were Rs. 1,624 and Rs. 4,458 and for a caesarean-section it was Rs. 5,935 and Rs. 14,276 respectively. There was considerable state-level variation in use of the JSY programme for normal deliveries (15% nationally; ranging from 0% in Goa to 43% in Madhya Pradesh) and the percentage of families having to borrow money to pay for a caesarean-section in a private institution (47% nationally; ranging from 7% in Goa to 69% in Bihar). Increased literacy and wealth were associated with a higher likelihood of an institutional delivery, higher OOPE but no major variations in use of the JSY.
Our study highlights the ongoing high OOPE and impoverishing impact of institutional care for deliveries in India. Supporting families in financial planning for maternity care, additional investment in the JSY programme and strengthening state level planning are required to increase the proportion of institutional deliveries.
高额自付费用(OOP)使家庭不愿寻求熟练/机构护理。“Janani Suraksha Yojana(JSY)是 2005 年推出的一项现金转移计划,旨在减轻 OOP 并促进贫困家庭的机构分娩,是印度政府实现千年发展目标(MDG)4 和 5 的努力的一部分。本研究的目的是按邦和联邦属地估算正常/剖宫产分娩、JSY 计划使用和与分娩相关的借款的 OOP 差异,并对印度家庭的社会人口特征进行分析。
对 2007-08 年的家庭层面调查(DLHS-3)数据进行二次分析。对机构分娩和家庭分娩的 JSY 计划使用率和家庭借款比例进行了估计。
2007/08 年,印度有一半(52%)的分娩是在家中进行的。接受机构分娩的女性的 OOP 仍然很高,邦和联邦属地之间存在相当大的差异。印度公立和私立机构正常分娩的平均 OOP(SD)分别为 1624 卢比和 4458 卢比,剖宫产的 OOP 分别为 5935 卢比和 14276 卢比。邦一级 JSY 计划在正常分娩中的使用率(全国平均 15%;从果阿的 0%到中央邦的 43%)和私立机构剖宫产借款家庭的比例(全国平均 47%;从果阿的 7%到比哈尔邦的 69%)存在相当大的差异。较高的识字率和财富与较高的机构分娩可能性、较高的 OOP 但 JSY 使用率没有明显差异相关。
我们的研究强调了印度分娩机构护理持续存在的高 OOP 和贫困影响。需要为家庭提供产妇保健财务规划方面的支持、对 JSY 计划进行额外投资以及加强邦一级规划,以提高机构分娩的比例。