Chua Gilbert T, Wong Roger Y
LKS Faculty of Medicine, University of Hong Kong, Hong Kong, China.
Can Geriatr J. 2011 Dec;14(4):93-9. doi: 10.57700/cgj.v14i4.23. Epub 2011 Dec 12.
The effectiveness of vitamin D in reducing falls among long-term care (LTC) seniors remains nonconclusive. We reviewed how vitamin D dosing regimen could affect rate of fall and number of fallers among LTC seniors.
We conducted a systematic literature review. Studies were selected by two independent reviewers based on study characteristics (age 75 or older), quality assessment (primary analysis randomized controlled trials), and outcome (rate of fall and number of fallers). Analyses of all trials following trials using daily standard dosage (800-1000 IU) only were performed to compare daily standard dosage with intermittent supratherapeutic dosage in fall prevention.
Seventy-nine studies were identified, with 28 selected by reviewers (kappa 0.98), and four RCT were conducted in LTC. Daily standard dosage provides greater reduction in rate of fall by 16%, which was statistically significant. However, reduction in number of fallers remained statistically insignificant even taking dosing regimen into account.
Daily standard dosage of vitamin D has greater benefits in reducing fall rate than that of intermittent supratherapeutic doses, but not in number of fallers. This could imply that vitamin D is useful in preventing fall recurrence rather than first fall. Prospective studies randomizing LTC seniors to different dosing regimens are warranted.
维生素D在降低长期护理(LTC)老年人跌倒风险方面的有效性尚无定论。我们回顾了维生素D给药方案如何影响LTC老年人的跌倒发生率和跌倒者数量。
我们进行了一项系统的文献综述。由两名独立评审员根据研究特征(年龄75岁及以上)、质量评估(主要分析为随机对照试验)和结果(跌倒发生率和跌倒者数量)选择研究。仅对使用每日标准剂量(800 - 1000国际单位)的试验后的所有试验进行分析,以比较每日标准剂量与间歇性超治疗剂量在预防跌倒方面的效果。
共识别出79项研究,评审员选择了28项(卡帕值为0.98),并在LTC中进行了4项随机对照试验。每日标准剂量可使跌倒发生率显著降低16%。然而,即使考虑给药方案,跌倒者数量的减少在统计学上仍不显著。
维生素D的每日标准剂量在降低跌倒发生率方面比间歇性超治疗剂量更有益,但在减少跌倒者数量方面并非如此。这可能意味着维生素D有助于预防跌倒复发而非首次跌倒。有必要进行前瞻性研究,将LTC老年人随机分配到不同的给药方案中。