Diamond S G, Markham C H, Hoehn M M, McDowell F H, Muenter M D
Department of Neurology, UCLA School of Medicine 90024-1769.
Neurology. 1990 May;40(5):763-6. doi: 10.1212/wnl.40.5.763.
We conducted disability and mortality studies to determine if the male preponderance usually found in Parkinson's disease (PD) was reflected in different courses of the diseases in the 2 sexes. We analyzed longitudinal disability score in 47 men and 23 women with PD followed for 6 years at UCLA. We found no significant differences between the sexes in mean disability scores in any of the 6 years. Mean dopa dosage was significantly higher in men, possibly reflecting their generally larger body mass. Choreoathetosis, dementia, or other side effects did not differ between the 2 groups. We obtained observed to expected mortality ratios in 239 men and 132 women followed for 3,831 person-years from records of 4 medical centers. Using the sex-specific US Life Tables to calculate expected mortality, we found the observed to expected ratio for the men was 1.7457 and for the women 2.4740, a significantly greater excess in female mortality. Analyses of mortality using tables which are not sex-specific will fail to uncover the decreased longevity in women with PD. We conclude that, despite the male preponderance in PD, men and women acquire it at the same age, have the same progression and duration of disease, and die at the same age; whereas, in the general population, women have a longer life expectancy than men. It is not known what factors protect women from incurring PD and what lowers their life expectancy to that of men when they do have the disease.
我们开展了残疾和死亡率研究,以确定帕金森病(PD)中常见的男性占优势情况是否体现在两性疾病的不同病程中。我们分析了加州大学洛杉矶分校(UCLA)随访6年的47名男性和23名女性帕金森病患者的纵向残疾评分。我们发现,在这6年中的任何一年,两性的平均残疾评分均无显著差异。男性的平均多巴剂量显著更高,这可能反映了他们总体上更大的体重。舞蹈徐动症、痴呆或其他副作用在两组之间没有差异。我们从4个医疗中心的记录中获取了239名男性和132名女性随访3831人年的观察到的与预期的死亡率比值。使用特定性别的美国生命表来计算预期死亡率,我们发现男性的观察到的与预期的比值为1.7457,女性为2.4740,女性死亡率的超额显著更大。使用非特定性别的表格进行死亡率分析将无法发现帕金森病女性患者的寿命缩短情况。我们得出结论,尽管帕金森病中男性占优势,但男性和女性患病年龄相同,疾病进展和病程相同,死亡年龄也相同;而在一般人群中,女性的预期寿命比男性长。尚不清楚哪些因素能保护女性不患帕金森病,以及当她们患病时是什么因素将其预期寿命降低到与男性相同的水平。