Department of Physical Therapy and Rehabilitation Science, University of Maryland School of Medicine, Baltimore, MD, USA.
J Vestib Res. 2012;22(5-6):283-98. doi: 10.3233/VES-120464.
Adults with bilateral vestibular hypofunction (BVH) experience significant disability. A systematic review assessed evidence for vestibular rehabilitation (VR). NUMBER OF STUDIES: 14 studies.
MATERIALS/METHODS: Search identification of studies based on inclusion criteria: (a) population: adults with BVH of peripheral origin; (b) interventions: vestibular exercises, balance training, education, or sensory prosthetics; (c) comparison: single interventions or compared to another psychophysical intervention, placebo, or healthy population; (d) outcomes: based on International Classification of Functioning, Disability and Health (ICF) Body Functions and Structure, Activity, and Participation; (e) study designs: prospective and interventional, Levels of Evidence I to III per Centre of Evidence-based Medicine grading. Coding and appraisal based on ICF framework and strength of evidence synthesis.
Five Level II studies and nine Level III studies: All had outcomes on gaze and postural stability, five with outcomes on gait speed and perceptions of oscillopsia and disequilibrium.
(a) Moderate evidence strength on improved gaze and postural stability (ICF-Body Functions) following exercise-based VR; (b) Inadequate number of studies supporting benefit of VR on ICF-Participation outcomes; (c) Sensory prosthetics in early phase of development.
Moderate evidence strength in support of VR from an impairment level; clinical practice and research needed to explore interventions extending to ICF-Activity and Participation.
双侧前庭功能低下(BVH)的成年人会经历严重的残疾。一项系统评价评估了前庭康复(VR)的证据。
14 项研究。
材料/方法:根据纳入标准搜索识别研究:(a)人群:外周性 BVH 的成年人;(b)干预措施:前庭运动、平衡训练、教育或感觉假体;(c)比较:单一干预或与另一种心理物理干预、安慰剂或健康人群比较;(d)结果:基于国际功能、残疾和健康分类(ICF)身体功能和结构、活动和参与;(e)研究设计:前瞻性和干预性,根据循证医学分级的证据中心,分为 I 级至 III 级。基于 ICF 框架和证据综合强度进行编码和评估。
五项 II 级研究和九项 III 级研究:所有研究均有眼动和姿势稳定性的结果,五项研究有步态速度以及对摆动幻觉和平衡失调的感知的结果。
(a)基于基于运动的 VR 改善眼动和姿势稳定性(ICF-身体功能)的中度证据强度;(b)支持 VR 对 ICF-参与结果有益的研究数量不足;(c)感觉假体处于早期开发阶段。
从损伤水平上有支持 VR 的中度证据强度;需要临床实践和研究来探索扩展到 ICF-活动和参与的干预措施。