Center for Chronic Disease Outcomes Research, Minneapolis Veterans Affairs Health Care System, USA.
Clin Psychol Rev. 2013 Mar;33(2):275-86. doi: 10.1016/j.cpr.2012.12.003. Epub 2012 Dec 22.
We reviewed randomized controlled trials conducted in the United States from January, 1996 through December, 2011 that examined family interventions for adult mental health conditions. We identified 51 articles (39 trials) evaluating 21 different family interventions. Findings for behavioral couple or family therapy (BCT/BFT) and community reinforcement and training (CRAFT) for substance use disorders were each pooled separately for examination in meta-analyses. Findings suggest BCT/BFT reduced substance use (small-to-moderate effects) and improved relationship adjustment (large effects) compared to individually-oriented treatments. CRAFT increased treatment initiation three-fold but did not improve substance use or family functioning over alternative family interventions. Family focused therapy for bipolar disorder improved symptoms over less intensive treatments with mixed findings when compared to equally intensive treatments. For both bipolar disorder and schizophrenia spectrum disorders, the few trials meeting our search criteria and heterogeneity among trials precluded generating broader conclusions regarding which family interventions are most effective for US populations. Overall, trials were limited in their methodological quality, and many interventions were evaluated in one trial. Future research is needed to replicate findings for these single trials, examine relationship distress as a moderator of outcome, and examine BCT/BFT among dual substance using couples and outside the research group frequently represented.
我们回顾了 1996 年 1 月至 2011 年 12 月期间在美国进行的随机对照试验,这些试验研究了针对成人心理健康状况的家庭干预措施。我们确定了 51 篇文章(39 项试验),评估了 21 种不同的家庭干预措施。针对行为夫妻或家庭疗法(BCT/BFT)和社区强化和培训(CRAFT)治疗物质使用障碍的研究结果分别进行了单独的荟萃分析。研究结果表明,与以个人为导向的治疗方法相比,BCT/BFT 减少了物质使用(小到中等效应),改善了人际关系调整(大效应)。CRAFT 将治疗开始率提高了三倍,但在物质使用或家庭功能方面并没有优于其他家庭干预措施。与低强度治疗相比,针对双相情感障碍的家庭焦点疗法改善了症状,但与同样强度的治疗相比,混合结果显示其改善程度较低。对于双相情感障碍和精神分裂症谱系障碍,符合我们搜索标准的试验数量有限,而且试验之间存在异质性,因此无法得出关于哪些家庭干预措施对美国人群最有效的更广泛结论。总体而言,这些试验在方法学质量上存在局限性,许多干预措施仅在一项试验中进行了评估。需要开展未来研究来复制这些单项试验的结果,检验关系困扰作为结果的调节因素,并在经常代表的双重物质使用夫妇和研究组之外,检验 BCT/BFT。