Interdisciplinary Center for Neural Computation, Hebrew University, Jerusalem 91904, Israel.
J Neurosci. 2013 Jan 16;33(3):1228-40. doi: 10.1523/JNEUROSCI.3181-12.2013.
One of the puzzling aspects in the visual attention literature is the discrepancy between electrophysiological and fMRI findings: whereas fMRI studies reveal strong attentional modulation in the earliest visual areas, single-unit and local field potential studies yielded mixed results. In addition, it is not clear to what extent spatial attention effects extend from early to high-order visual areas. Here we addressed these issues using electrocorticography recordings in epileptic patients. The patients performed a task that allowed simultaneous manipulation of both spatial and object-based attention. They were presented with composite stimuli, consisting of a small object (face or house) superimposed on a large one, and in separate blocks, were instructed to attend one of the objects. We found a consistent increase in broadband high-frequency (30-90 Hz) power, but not in visual evoked potentials, associated with spatial attention starting with V1/V2 and continuing throughout the visual hierarchy. The magnitude of the attentional modulation was correlated with the spatial selectivity of each electrode and its distance from the occipital pole. Interestingly, the latency of the attentional modulation showed a significant decrease along the visual hierarchy. In addition, electrodes placed over high-order visual areas (e.g., fusiform gyrus) showed both effects of spatial and object-based attention. Overall, our results help to reconcile previous observations of discrepancy between fMRI and electrophysiology. They also imply that spatial attention effects can be found both in early and high-order visual cortical areas, in parallel with their stimulus tuning properties.
视觉注意力文献中的一个令人困惑的方面是电生理学和功能磁共振成像(fMRI)发现之间的差异:尽管 fMRI 研究揭示了在最早的视觉区域中存在强烈的注意力调节,但单细胞和局部场电位研究得出的结果却不一致。此外,目前尚不清楚空间注意力效应在多大程度上从早期视觉区域扩展到高级视觉区域。在这里,我们使用癫痫患者的皮层脑电图记录来解决这些问题。患者执行了一项任务,该任务允许同时操纵空间和基于对象的注意力。他们被呈现复合刺激,由一个小物体(脸或房子)叠加在一个大物体上,并在单独的块中,被指示注意一个物体。我们发现,从 V1/V2 开始并贯穿整个视觉层次,宽带高频(30-90 Hz)功率持续增加,但视觉诱发电位没有增加,与空间注意力相关。注意力调制的幅度与每个电极的空间选择性及其与枕极的距离相关。有趣的是,注意力调制的潜伏期沿视觉层次结构显著降低。此外,放置在高级视觉区域(例如梭状回)上的电极同时显示出空间和基于对象的注意力的影响。总的来说,我们的结果有助于调和 fMRI 和电生理学之间以前观察到的差异。它们还意味着空间注意力效应可以在早期和高级视觉皮质区域中同时找到,与它们的刺激调谐特性一致。