Hamedi Rad Fahimeh, Ghaffari Tahereh, Safavi Sayed Hamed
Assistant Professor, Department of Prosthodontics, Faculty of Dentistry, Tabriz University of Medical Sciences, Tabriz, Iran.
J Dent Res Dent Clin Dent Prospects. 2010 Fall;4(4):130-5. doi: 10.5681/joddd.2010.032. Epub 2010 Dec 21.
The most common method for alginate impression disinfection is spraying it with disinfecting agents, but some studies have shown that these impressions can be immersed, too. The aim of this study was to evaluate the dimensional stability of alginate impressions following disinfecting by spray and immersion methods.
Four common disinfecting agents (Sodium Hypochlorite, Micro 10, Glutaraldehyde and De-conex) were selected and the impressions (n=108) were divided into four groups (n=24) and eight subgroups (n=12) for disinfecting by any of the four above-mentioned agents by spray or immersion methods. The control group (n=12) was not disinfected. Then the impressions were poured by type III Dental Stone Plaster in a standard method. The results were ana-lyzed by descriptive methods (mean and standard deviation), t-test, two-way analysis of variance (ANOVA) and Duncan test, using SPSS 14.0 software for windows.
The mean changes of length and height were significant between the various groups and disinfecting methods. Regarding the length, the greatest and the least amounts were related to Deconex and Micro 10 in the immersion method, respectively. Regarding height, the greatest and the least amounts were related to Glutaraldehyde and Deconex in the im-mersion method, respectively.
Disinfecting alginate impressions by Sodium Hypochlorite, Deconex and Glutaraldehyde by immersion method is not recommended and it is better to disinfect alginate impressions by spraying of Micro 10, Sodium Hypochlorite, Glutaraldehyde and immersion in Micro 10.
藻酸盐印模消毒最常用的方法是用消毒剂喷雾,但一些研究表明这些印模也可浸泡消毒。本研究的目的是评估藻酸盐印模经喷雾和浸泡消毒方法后的尺寸稳定性。
选择四种常用消毒剂(次氯酸钠、Micro 10、戊二醛和德康洁),将印模(n = 108)分为四组(n = 24)和八个亚组(n = 12),通过上述四种消毒剂中的任何一种采用喷雾或浸泡方法进行消毒。对照组(n = 12)不进行消毒。然后用III型牙科石膏以标准方法灌注印模。使用适用于Windows的SPSS 14.0软件,通过描述性方法(均值和标准差)、t检验、双向方差分析(ANOVA)和邓肯检验对结果进行分析。
不同组和消毒方法之间长度和高度的平均变化具有显著性。关于长度,浸泡法中最大和最小变化量分别与德康洁和Micro 10有关。关于高度,浸泡法中最大和最小变化量分别与戊二醛和德康洁有关。
不建议采用浸泡法用次氯酸钠、德康洁和戊二醛对藻酸盐印模进行消毒,最好采用喷雾法用Micro 10、次氯酸钠、戊二醛对藻酸盐印模进行消毒,以及用Micro 10浸泡消毒。