Department of Public Health, University of Oxford, UK.
Med Teach. 2013 May;35(5):365-75. doi: 10.3109/0142159X.2012.746450. Epub 2013 Jan 29.
To compare specialty choices of the UK medical graduates of 2005, 2008 and 2009, one year after graduation, with those of graduates from previous years and with the distribution of senior medical practitioners working in England.
Postal questionnaire surveys.
The proportion of graduates giving more than one specialty choice rose in the most recent cohorts. Among men, choices for surgical careers fell from 37% of 2005 graduates to 25% of 2008 and 2009 graduates. The percentages who specified anaesthetics, general practice and obstetrics and gynaecology rose. Among women, general practice and surgery were unchanged in popularity, but increasing percentages specified paediatrics, anaesthetics and obstetrics and gynaecology. Choices for psychiatry and emergency medicine showed no trend. General practice was substantially under-represented, and hospital surgical and medical specialties were over-represented, in choices when compared to the distribution of senior National Health Service doctors.
More current graduates consider two or more specialties than did their predecessors, which may reflect an increase in uncertainty about obtaining a post in their favoured specialty. The specialty preferences expressed by newly qualified doctors, notably the shortfall in numbers choosing general practice, remain inconsistent with future service needs.
比较 2005、2008 和 2009 年英国医学毕业生在毕业后一年的专业选择,与往年毕业生的分布情况以及在英格兰工作的高级医务人员的分布情况。
邮寄问卷调查。
最近几届毕业生中,选择多个专业的比例有所上升。在男性中,选择外科职业的比例从 2005 届毕业生的 37%下降到 2008 届和 2009 届毕业生的 25%。指定麻醉科、全科医学和妇产科的比例有所上升。在女性中,全科医学和外科的受欢迎程度保持不变,但越来越多的人指定儿科、麻醉科和妇产科。精神病学和急诊医学的选择没有趋势。与高级国民保健制度医生的分布相比,全科医学的选择明显不足,而医院外科和内科专业则选择过多。
与前辈相比,现在的毕业生中有更多的人考虑两个或更多的专业,这可能反映出在获得自己喜欢的专业职位方面的不确定性增加。新获得资格的医生所表达的专业偏好,尤其是选择全科医学的人数不足,仍然与未来的服务需求不一致。