Abdul Razzak Rima
Department of Physiology, Arabian Gulf University, Manama, Kingdom of Bahrain.
Appl Neuropsychol Adult. 2013;20(1):53-60. doi: 10.1080/09084282.2012.670163. Epub 2012 Oct 23.
The Trail-Making Test (TMT) is used in different neuropsychological test batteries. It consists of two parts: TMT-Part A, which tests visual scanning and psychomotor speed, and TMT-Part B, which assesses more complex cognitive processes. TMT normative data have been established in many non-Arab countries either using the original English version or a version developed with the native language. The aim of this study was to compare TMT performance between the English TMT and a constructed Arabic TMT in young Arabic-English bilingual college students from three Arabian Gulf states. Scores from 83 participants who took the English TMT and 52 who took the Arabic TMT were included. Arabic TMT (both parts) scores were significantly poorer compared with English TMT scores. Arabic TMT scores were also poorer than were other norms for this age group and education level, but they were better than those reported from another study using the Arabic TMT. Moreover, there were nonsignificant differences in performance between participants from these three countries; however, these findings are inconclusive as sample sizes were small. These findings suggest that Arabic TMT norms cannot be unified for all Arabic countries, and separate Arabic TMT norms including all age groups and education levels must be established for each Arabic country.
连线测验(TMT)用于不同的神经心理测验组合中。它由两部分组成:TMT-A部分,测试视觉扫描和心理运动速度;TMT-B部分,评估更复杂的认知过程。在许多非阿拉伯国家,已使用原始英文版或用本国语言开发的版本建立了TMT常模数据。本研究的目的是比较来自三个海湾国家的年轻阿拉伯-英语双语大学生在英文TMT和自编阿拉伯语TMT上的表现。纳入了83名参加英文TMT的参与者和52名参加阿拉伯语TMT的参与者的分数。与英文TMT分数相比,阿拉伯语TMT(两部分)分数明显更低。阿拉伯语TMT分数也低于该年龄组和教育水平的其他常模,但优于另一项使用阿拉伯语TMT的研究报告的分数。此外,这三个国家的参与者在表现上没有显著差异;然而,由于样本量较小,这些发现尚无定论。这些发现表明,不能为所有阿拉伯国家统一阿拉伯语TMT常模,必须为每个阿拉伯国家建立包括所有年龄组和教育水平的单独阿拉伯语TMT常模。