Asgary Saeed, Motazedian Hamid Reza, Parirokh Masoud, Eghbal Mohammad Jafar, Kheirieh Sanam
Iranian Center for Endodontic Research, Research Institute of Dental Sciences, Shahid Beheshti University of Medical Sciences, Tehran, Iran.
Iran Endod J. 2013 Winter;8(1):1-5. Epub 2013 Jan 20.
Mineral trioxide aggregate (MTA) has been suggested for root-end filling, vital pulp therapy, apical plug, perforations repair, and root canal filling. Since the introduction of MTA in 1993, many studies about this material have been published. The aim of this survey was to illustrate statistical information about published articles in PubMed-index journals vis-à-vis the various aspects of this biomaterial.
A PubMed search was performed to retrieve the relative articles from 1993 to August 2012. The data of each article including publication year, journal name, number of authors, first author name, affiliations and study design were recorded. Citation of each article till 2009 was obtained from Scopus and Google scholar databases. Data were analyzed to determine the related scientometric indicators.
In total, 1027 articles were found in PubMed-indexed journals which show considerable increase from 2 papers in 1993 to 139 in 2011. While 62% of articles had no level of evidence, only ~5% could be classified as having the highest level of evidence (LOE1); however, the majority of LOE1 articles originated from Iran (1%: n=10). Journal of Endodontics, as the top rank journal, published 31.7% of MTA related articles. The majority of articles were four-authored (19.6%). Most of the articles originated from USA (21.9%), Brazil (18.5%) and Iran (8.76%). The average number of citation for the top ten articles from Scopus was 231.
This data demonstrates that during the past two decades, research on this novel endodontic biomaterial had a rapid positive trend especially during the last 5 years. Further high-level evidence articles for the various clinical applications of MTA would result in superior clinical decision making and stronger scientific-based endodontic practice.
矿物三氧化物凝聚体(MTA)已被用于根尖倒充填、活髓治疗、根尖阻塞、穿孔修复及根管充填。自1993年MTA问世以来,已有许多关于该材料的研究发表。本调查旨在阐述PubMed索引期刊上发表的有关这种生物材料各个方面的文章的统计信息。
在PubMed上进行检索,以获取1993年至2012年8月的相关文章。记录每篇文章的数据,包括发表年份、期刊名称、作者数量、第一作者姓名、所属机构及研究设计。截至2009年每篇文章的引用情况从Scopus和谷歌学术数据库获取。对数据进行分析以确定相关的科学计量指标。
在PubMed索引期刊上共找到1027篇文章,从1993年的2篇增至2011年的139篇,呈现出显著增长。虽然约62%的文章没有证据水平,只有约5%可归类为具有最高证据水平(证据水平1);然而,大多数证据水平1的文章来自伊朗(约1%:n = 10)。作为排名第一的期刊,《牙髓病学杂志》发表了31.7%的与MTA相关的文章。大多数文章有四位作者(19.6%)。大多数文章来自美国(21.9%)、巴西(18.5%)和伊朗(8.76%)。Scopus收录的前十篇文章的平均引用次数为231次。
这些数据表明,在过去二十年中,对这种新型牙髓生物材料的研究呈现出快速积极的趋势,尤其是在过去五年。关于MTA各种临床应用的更多高水平证据文章将有助于做出更优的临床决策,并加强基于科学的牙髓治疗实践。