Tompkins David Andrew, Smith Michael T, Bigelow George E, Moaddel Ruin, Venkata Swarajya Lakshmi Vatem, Strain Eric C
Departments of *Psychiatry and Behavioral Sciences, Behavioral Pharmacology Research Unit †Psychiatry and Behavioral Sciences, Behavioral Sleep Medicine Program, Johns Hopkins University School of Medicine ‡Intramural Research Program, National Institute on Aging, Baltimore, MD.
Clin J Pain. 2014 Jan;30(1):36-45. doi: 10.1097/AJP.0b013e3182851758.
Opioid-induced hyperalgesia (OIH), increased sensitivity to noxious stimuli after repeated opioid exposures, has been demonstrated in preclinical studies. However, there is no accepted, prospective model of OIH after repeated opioid exposures currently available in humans. This study assessed a potential prospective OIH model.
Double-blind intramuscular injections of a short-acting opioid (alfentanil 15 mcg/kg; N=8) were compared to active placebo (diphenhydramine 25 mg; N=3) on cold and pressure pain testing and standard abuse liability measures in eight 10-hour sessions (1 injection/session) over 4 to 5 weeks in healthy, pain-free males. Decreases from session baseline pain threshold (PThr) and tolerance (PTol) were calculated to represent hyperalgesia, and were assessed both within and across sessions.
Mean decreases in cold PTol were seen in the alfentanil group at 180 minutes (-3.8 s, ±26.5) and 480 minutes (-1.63 s, ±31.5) after drug administration. There was a trend for differences between conditions on cold PThr hyperalgesia but not for pressure PThr. Alfentanil participants had greater mean ratings on Liking and High visual analog scales at peak effects (30 min), but these scores did not change across sessions.
Repeated alfentanil exposures over 4 to 5 weeks resulted in within session decreases in cold pain tolerance from baseline but these differences were not substantially different from diphenhydramine controls. The results did not support the phenomenon of OIH in this model, although definitive conclusions regarding the existence of OIH in humans likely requires a larger sample size or an alternative model.
阿片类药物诱导的痛觉过敏(OIH),即重复使用阿片类药物后对伤害性刺激的敏感性增加,已在临床前研究中得到证实。然而,目前尚无公认的、针对人类重复使用阿片类药物后的前瞻性OIH模型。本研究评估了一种潜在的前瞻性OIH模型。
在4至5周内,对健康、无疼痛的男性进行8次10小时的实验(每次实验注射1次),将短效阿片类药物(阿芬太尼15微克/千克;N = 8)与活性安慰剂(苯海拉明25毫克;N = 3)进行双盲肌肉注射,并比较其在冷痛和压痛测试以及标准滥用倾向测量方面的效果。计算每次实验相对于基线疼痛阈值(PThr)和耐受性(PTol)的降低值以代表痛觉过敏,并在实验内和实验间进行评估。
阿芬太尼组在给药后180分钟(-3.8秒,±26.5)和480分钟(-1.63秒,±31.5)时,冷痛PTol出现平均降低。在冷痛PThr痛觉过敏方面,不同条件之间存在差异趋势,但在压痛PThr方面则没有。阿芬太尼组参与者在峰值效应(30分钟)时对喜好和高视觉模拟量表的平均评分更高,但这些分数在各次实验中没有变化。
在4至5周内重复使用阿芬太尼导致实验内冷痛耐受性相对于基线有所降低,但这些差异与苯海拉明对照组相比并无显著差异。尽管关于人类是否存在OIH的明确结论可能需要更大的样本量或替代模型,但本研究结果并不支持该模型中的OIH现象。