Hagberg J M, King D S, Rogers M A, Montain S J, Jilka S M, Kohrt W M, Heller S L
Department of Medicine, Jerry Lewis Neuromuscular Research Center, St. Louis, Missouri.
J Appl Physiol (1985). 1990 Apr;68(4):1393-8. doi: 10.1152/jappl.1990.68.4.1393.
This study was designed to determine whether patients with McArdle's disease, who do not increase their blood lactate levels during and after maximal exercise, have a slow "lactacid" component to their recovery O2 consumption (VO2) response after high-intensity exercise. VO2 was measured breath by breath during 6 min of rest before exercise, a progressive maximal cycle ergometer test, and 15 min of recovery in five McArdle's patients, six age-matched control subjects, and six maximal O2 consumption- (VO2 max) matched control subjects. The McArdle's patients' ventilatory threshold occurred at the same relative exercise intensity [71 +/- 7% (SD) VO2max] as in the control groups (60 +/- 13 and 70 +/- 10% VO2max) despite no increase and a 20% decrease in the McArdle's patients' arterialized blood lactate and H+ levels, respectively. The recovery VO2 responses of all three groups were better fit by a two-, than a one-, component exponential model, and the parameters of the slow component of the recovery VO2 response were the same in the three groups. The presence of the same slow component of the recovery VO2 response in the McArdle's patients and the control subjects, despite the lack of an increase in blood lactate or H+ levels during maximal exercise and recovery in the patients, provides evidence that this portion of the recovery VO2 response is not the result of a lactacid mechanism. In addition, it appears that the hyperventilation that accompanies high-intensity exercise may be the result of some mechanism other than acidosis or lung CO2 flux.
本研究旨在确定患有麦卡德尔氏病的患者在最大运动期间及之后其血乳酸水平不升高,在高强度运动后的恢复耗氧量(VO₂)反应中是否具有缓慢的“乳酸”成分。在五名麦卡德尔氏病患者、六名年龄匹配的对照受试者以及六名最大耗氧量(VO₂ max)匹配的对照受试者中,在运动前6分钟休息期间、进行递增式最大功率自行车测力计测试期间以及恢复15分钟期间逐次测量VO₂。尽管麦卡德尔氏病患者的动脉化血乳酸和H⁺水平分别未升高且下降了20%,但其通气阈值出现时的相对运动强度[71±7%(标准差)VO₂ max]与对照组(60±13%和70±10% VO₂ max)相同。所有三组的恢复VO₂反应用双成分指数模型比单成分指数模型拟合得更好,并且三组中恢复VO₂反应慢成分的参数相同。尽管麦卡德尔氏病患者在最大运动及恢复期间血乳酸或H⁺水平未升高,但患者和对照受试者中恢复VO₂反应存在相同的慢成分,这证明恢复VO₂反应的这一部分不是乳酸机制的结果。此外,似乎高强度运动时伴随的过度通气可能是酸中毒或肺二氧化碳通量以外的某种机制导致的。