Kacar Gulizar, Kacar Cahit, Gungor Firat
Akdeniz University School of Medicine , Department of Nuclear Medicine, Antalya, Turkey.
Mol Imaging Radionucl Ther. 2011 Aug;20(2):45-51. doi: 10.4274/MIRT.24. Epub 2011 Aug 1.
In this study, it was aimed to investigate the agreement between early phase of bone scintigraphy - human immunoglobulin scintigraphy (EPBS-HIG) and late phase bone scintigraphy - HIG (LPBS-HIG) in the determination of the presence and also the severity of inflammatory arthritis.
Twenty-eight patients (23 female, 5 male; between 19 to 80 years of age) with inflammatory arthritis were included in the study. Tc-99m HIG and blood pool/late phase bone scintigraphies were performed in all patients. In scintigraphic examinations, the joints were scored with the degree of accumulation of the radiopharmaceutical by the semiquantitative analysis (0=Background activity, 1=Faint uptake, 2=Moderate uptake, 3=Marked uptake) which is called as visually active joint score as severity index of the disease. To estimate the agreement between EPBS - HIG and LPBS - HIG in the determination of the presence and severity of inflammatory arthritis, 2x2 kappa coefficients were calculated.
Our results showed good agreement between EPBS - HIG for the presence of inflammation (kappa: 0.72) but not for the severity of the disease (kappa: 0.29), poor agreement between LPBS - HIG for both the presence (kappa: 0.51) and severity (kappa: 0.01) of inflammatory arthritis.
The blood pool scintigraphy could be used in the investigation of the presence of inflammatory arthritis because the good agreement with HIG and the lower cost but not for the severity of the disease Conflict of interest:None declared.
本研究旨在探讨早期骨闪烁显像-人免疫球蛋白闪烁显像(EPBS-HIG)与晚期骨闪烁显像-人免疫球蛋白闪烁显像(LPBS-HIG)在确定炎症性关节炎的存在及严重程度方面的一致性。
本研究纳入了28例炎症性关节炎患者(23例女性,5例男性;年龄在19至80岁之间)。所有患者均进行了Tc-99m人免疫球蛋白闪烁显像及血池/晚期骨闪烁显像。在闪烁显像检查中,通过半定量分析(0=背景活性,1=轻度摄取,2=中度摄取,3=明显摄取)对关节进行放射性药物积聚程度评分,该评分称为视觉活性关节评分,作为疾病严重程度指标。为评估EPBS-HIG与LPBS-HIG在确定炎症性关节炎的存在及严重程度方面的一致性,计算了2×2卡帕系数。
我们的结果显示,EPBS-HIG在炎症存在方面一致性良好(卡帕值:0.72),但在疾病严重程度方面一致性不佳(卡帕值:0.29);LPBS-HIG在炎症性关节炎的存在(卡帕值:0.51)及严重程度(卡帕值:0.01)方面一致性均较差。
血池闪烁显像可用于炎症性关节炎存在情况的研究,因为它与HIG一致性良好且成本较低,但不适用于疾病严重程度的评估。利益冲突:未声明。