Uznańska-Loch Barbara, Trzos Ewa, Wierzbowska-Drabik Karina, Smigielski Janusz, Rechciński Tomasz, Cieślik-Guerra Urszula, Kasprzak Jarosław D, Kurpesa Małgorzata
Chair and Clinic of Cardiology, Medical University of Łódź, Łódź, 91-347 Poland.
Ann Noninvasive Electrocardiol. 2013 Mar;18(2):163-9. doi: 10.1111/anec.12012. Epub 2012 Nov 22.
In patients with systolic heart failure (HF), coexisting sleep apnea may promote arrhythmia. Ambulatory Holter electrocardiogram (ECG) monitoring (AECG) is a method of arrhythmia and apnea evaluation. We hypothesized that 24-hour AECG in patients with HF who have a high risk of serious arrhythmia may be less accurate than AECG extended to 48 hours and that, moreover, arrhythmia may be related to apnea.
Eighty-four recordings of 48-hour AECG in 84 patients with ischemic HF (mean ejection fraction 34 ± 7%) were analyzed. Day 1, Day 2 were checked for ventricular tachycardia (VT) and supraventricular tachycardia (SVT). Estimated apnea-hypopnea index (est.AHI) was calculated using Holter, monitoring where est.AHI >15 indicates apnea.
In 48-hour AECG, VT occurred in 34 patients (40.5%) whereas SVT in 17 patients (20.2%), and patients with est.AHI > 15 had higher VT occurrence. In two-sample one-sided test for proportions, 24-hour AECG from Day 1 showed a significantly lower percentage of patients with detected VT than 48-hour AECG-it was 23.8% (20 patients), meaning a significant underestimation with P = 0.0089. We assessed VT underestimation in the subgroups with regard to est.AHI, and found that it was present in Day 1 monitoring in the subgroups with est.AHI > 15. It was absent in the subgroups with est.AHI ≤ 15 and also in Day 2 monitoring.
In patients with systolic HF, 24-hour AECG may have insufficient sensitivity regarding serious arrhythmia occurrence. If significant apnea was detected in the first day, extending the monitoring may be recommended.
在收缩性心力衰竭(HF)患者中,并存的睡眠呼吸暂停可能会促发心律失常。动态心电图监测(AECG)是一种评估心律失常和呼吸暂停的方法。我们推测,对于有严重心律失常高风险的HF患者,24小时AECG可能不如延长至48小时的AECG准确,此外,心律失常可能与呼吸暂停有关。
对84例缺血性HF患者(平均射血分数34±7%)的84份48小时AECG记录进行了分析。检查第1天、第2天的室性心动过速(VT)和室上性心动过速(SVT)情况。使用动态心电图监测计算估计的呼吸暂停低通气指数(est.AHI),其中est.AHI>15表示呼吸暂停。
在48小时AECG中,34例患者(40.5%)发生VT,17例患者(20.2%)发生SVT,est.AHI>15的患者VT发生率更高。在比例的双样本单侧检验中,第1天的24小时AECG显示检测到VT的患者百分比显著低于48小时AECG——为23.8%(20例患者),这意味着存在显著低估,P = 0.0089。我们评估了est.AHI亚组中的VT低估情况,发现在est.AHI>15的亚组第1天监测中存在低估。在est.AHI≤15的亚组以及第2天监测中未出现低估。
对于收缩性HF患者,24小时AECG在严重心律失常发生方面的敏感性可能不足。如果在第一天检测到明显的呼吸暂停,建议延长监测时间。