Sieving Renee E, McMorris Barbara J, Secor-Turner Molly, Garwick Ann W, Shlafer Rebecca, Beckman Kara J, Pettingell Sandra L, Oliphant Jennifer A, Seppelt Ann M
School of Nursing, University of Minnesota, 5-160 Weaver-Densford Hall, 308 Harvard Street S.E, Minneapolis, MN, 55455-0342, USA,
Prev Sci. 2014 Aug;15(4):460-72. doi: 10.1007/s11121-013-0387-5.
Prime Time, a youth development intervention, aims to reduce multiple risk behaviors among adolescent girls seeking clinic services who are at high risk for pregnancy. The purpose of the current study was to examine whether Prime Time involvement produced changes in relational aggression, physical violence, and related psychosocial and behavioral outcomes. Qualitative case exemplars illustrated social contexts of intervention participants with differing longitudinal patterns of relational aggression and physical violence. Data were from a randomized efficacy trial with 13-17 year-old girls (n = 253) meeting specified risk criteria. Intervention participants were involved in Prime Time and usual clinic services for 18 months, control participants received usual clinic services. Participants in the current study completed self-report surveys at baseline and 18 months following enrollment. Outcomes analyses revealed significantly lower levels of relational aggression perpetration in the intervention group versus controls. In contrast, Prime Time involvement did not result in significant reductions in physical violence. Exploratory dose-response analyses indicated that reductions in relational aggression may have been most pronounced among girls actively involved in Prime Time case management and peer leadership activities. Qualitative findings suggested that the intervention's emphasis on modeling and building supportive relationships contributed to reductions in relational aggression. This study contributes to what has been a very limited evidence base regarding effective approaches to preventing violence among high-risk adolescent girls. Findings suggest that offering youth development interventions through clinic settings hold promise in reducing violence risk among vulnerable youth.
“黄金时间”是一项青少年发展干预项目,旨在减少寻求门诊服务且怀孕风险较高的少女中的多种危险行为。本研究的目的是检验参与“黄金时间”项目是否会使关系攻击、身体暴力以及相关的心理社会和行为结果发生变化。定性案例样本说明了干预参与者在关系攻击和身体暴力方面具有不同纵向模式的社会背景。数据来自一项针对符合特定风险标准的13至17岁女孩(n = 253)的随机疗效试验。干预组参与者参与了“黄金时间”项目和常规门诊服务,为期18个月,对照组参与者仅接受常规门诊服务。本研究的参与者在基线时以及入组18个月后完成了自我报告调查。结果分析显示,与对照组相比,干预组的关系攻击行为水平显著降低。相比之下,参与“黄金时间”项目并未导致身体暴力行为显著减少。探索性剂量反应分析表明,关系攻击行为的减少在积极参与“黄金时间”项目个案管理和同伴领导活动的女孩中可能最为明显。定性研究结果表明,该干预措施对榜样作用和建立支持性人际关系的强调有助于减少关系攻击行为。本研究为预防高危少女暴力行为的有效方法这一非常有限的证据基础做出了贡献。研究结果表明,通过门诊环境提供青少年发展干预措施有望降低弱势青少年的暴力风险。