Lowe Sarah R, Dillon Colleen O, Rhodes Jean E, Zwiebach Liza
University of Massachusetts Boston, Boston, MA, USA.
J Adolesc Res. 2013 Jan 1;28(1):31-68. doi: 10.1177/0743558411435854. Epub 2012 Feb 22.
This study explored the roles and psychological experiences identified as defining adult moments using mixed methods with a racially, ethnically, and socioeconomically diverse sample of young adults both enrolled and not enrolled in college ( = 726; ages 18-35). First, we evaluated results from a single survey item that asked participants to rate how adult they feel. Consistent with previous research, the majority of participants (56.9%) reported feeling "somewhat like an adult," and older participants had significantly higher subjective adulthood, controlling for other demographic variables. Next, we analyzed responses from an open-ended question asking participants to describe instances in which they felt like an adult. Responses covered both traditional roles (e.g., marriage, childbearing; 36.1%) and nontraditional social roles and experiences (e.g., moving out of parent's home, cohabitation; 55.6%). Although we found no differences by age and college status in the likelihood of citing a traditional or nontraditional role, participants who had achieved more traditional roles were more likely to cite them in their responses. In addition, responses were coded for psychological experiences, including responsibility for self (19.0%), responsibility for others (15.3%), self-regulation (31.1%), and reflected appraisals (5.1%). Older participants were significantly more likely to include self-regulation and reflected appraisals, whereas younger participants were more likely to include responsibility for self. College students were more likely than noncollege students to include self-regulation and reflected appraisals. Implications for research and practice are discussed.
本研究采用混合方法,以一个在种族、民族和社会经济方面具有多样性的青年样本(n = 726;年龄在18 - 35岁之间,包括已上大学和未上大学的青年)为对象,探讨了被视为成年时刻定义特征的角色和心理体验。首先,我们评估了一个单一调查项目的结果,该项目要求参与者对自己感觉有多成熟进行评分。与之前的研究一致,大多数参与者(56.9%)报告感觉“有点像成年人”,并且在控制了其他人口统计学变量后,年龄较大的参与者主观成年程度显著更高。接下来,我们分析了一个开放式问题的回答,该问题要求参与者描述他们感觉自己像成年人的事例。回答涵盖了传统角色(如结婚、生育;36.1%)和非传统社会角色及经历(如搬离父母家、同居;55.6%)。尽管我们发现年龄和大学状态在提及传统或非传统角色的可能性上没有差异,但实现了更多传统角色的参与者在回答中更有可能提及这些角色。此外,回答还根据心理体验进行了编码,包括对自己的责任(19.0%)、对他人的责任(15.3%)、自我调节(31.1%)和反思性评价(5.1%)。年龄较大的参与者显著更有可能提及自我调节和反思性评价,而年龄较小的参与者更有可能提及对自己的责任。大学生比非大学生更有可能提及自我调节和反思性评价。文中讨论了本研究对研究和实践的启示。